E. Caperrell
| Age: | |
| Died: | 16th Nov 1864 |
| Accident: | 16th Nov 1864 |
| Born: | |
| Colliery: | Withymore |
| Company: | Messrs. Nock |
| Occupation: | |
| Notes: | Fell down the shaft part way ; the chain broke |
| Buried: | [not known] |
| Category: | |
Shaft accidents.
The most serious accident in my district during the year, No. 77 in the "list,"
by occurred on Wednesday evening, November 16th, at the Withymoor Colliery, near
Rowley Regis, which is worked by Messrs. Edwin and Joseph Nock. A skip containing
eight men and boys was being raised at about a quarter past six o'clock, when the
chain caught on one of the horns of the drum, and falling off upon one of the angles
of the square "drum-shaft," snapped, and the skip, with its eight occupants, fell a
distance of about 70 yards, a length of chain of about 90 yards falling upon them. All
the poor fellows were killed on the spot. An inspection of the pit and the "winding
apparatus" after the accident rendered the cause of this terrible calamity evident. The
chain was a very good one, and on being tested bore a strain of 19 tons 3 cwts. The
defect to which this serious waste of life was due was that the pit-frame which supported
the "pulley," over which the chain worked, had been allowed to get out of the perpendicular
to the extent, as I ascertained after the accident, of about 15½ inches, the result
of which was, that the chain caught on one of the "horns" of the drum on the side
towards which the "frame" leaned, which it was clear had been the case for some time
past from the wearing of the horns on that side ; and when the accident occurred, as was
stated by the man who was working the engine, the chain first caught on the point of
one of the horns, and as the drum revolved, fell off upon the square drum shaft, the sharp
angle of which, with the force of the concussion, caused it to snap.
Three separate inquests were held in respect to different sufferers, and one of these
was presided over by Brook Robinson, Esquire, coroner for Worcestershire ; and the other
two by Edwin Hooper, Esquire, one of the Staffordshire coroners.
The cause of the accident was clear, but the juries, as is often the case, experienced
considerable difficulty in ascertaining who was responsible for the defective state of the
winding apparatus; and the result was that each jury returned a verdict involving the
charge of manslaughter, but in each case against different persons, the last which sat
expressly exonerating the persons committed for trial on the finding of the juries which
had sat previously.
It was fully proved by the evidence given at the inquests that the frame which
supported the "pulley" had been sinking for a considerable time, owing to a subterraneous
fire a few feet below the surface, which caused a continuous subsidence,
which had been greater on one side than the other. The frame had often been adjusted
in consequence, by raising the depressed "leg." At this, as at other collieries in that
part of South Staffordshire, work had been entirely suspended for some weeks, until
within a very short time of the fatal occurrence, by a strike of the colliers; and there is
little doubt that during that time the subsidence had gone on to a considerable extent,
and it was proved that, to use the words of the workmen, the leg of the frame had been
several times "pecked up" since the working of the colliers had been resumed after the
strike. It was evident that grievous neglect had been shown in not more carefully
watching the subsidence which was well known to be going on, and in not taking
effectual means to make the "pulley" frame firm and true. The difficulty was to see
who was responsible for this neglect.
The partner, who took the general management of the colliery, was Mr. Edwin Nock,
and up to three weeks before the accident there was a "head engineer,"
Crispin Southall, who took the general oversight of the engines and winding and pumping
apparatus at the various pits, and who stated that the sinking had been going on for
twelve months before the accident, but that he left the frame upright and in good order
when the colliery started after the strike, and that whilst he was engineer Mr. Edwin
Nock had given him strict injunctions to examine it every day.
At the first inquest Mr. Nock stated that after Southall left he employed in his place
an engineer named James Leedham, and the jury evidently inferred that this man took
Southall's place as head engineer.
The engine-man, who was working the engine where the chain broke, was Francis Downing,
and in his own evidence he said the frame had been raised two or three times
during the month previous to the accident, and was so raised four days before ; and he
also said that the chain rubbed against the horns and the flange of the pulley, and he
acknowledged that he did not consider the machinery safe to work that day, yet he never
made any complaint to any one.
The banksman deposed, that when the frame was raised it was done by the orders of
Zechariah Mason, the manager of the colliery, and he said he had mentioned the sinking
of the frame to "Mason" a few days before the accident. Mason was himself called,
and said he knew nothing about the machinery being out of gear, and that no one had
told him of it. The result of this first inquiry was a verdict of manslaughter against
Zechariah Mason, as manager of the pit, and Joseph Leedham as head-engineer.
At the second inquest, before Mr. Hooper, coroner for Staffordshire, Mr. Edwin Nock,
one of the proprietors, stated that Downing, the man in charge of the engine in question,
was alone responsible for the machinery at that pit; that Leedham had nothing whatever
to do with the pit where the accident occurred ; and that Mason was only the "deputy
or doggy," and was not responsible for the machinery. The result of this inquiry was a
of manslaughter against Mr. Edwin Nock, one of the proprietors of the colliery.
At the third inquest, also before Mr. Hooper, it was shown that Mason went down the
pit on the morning before the accident, and he said that the skip did not touch the side
of the shaft. The banksman said he told Mason that there was something wrong about
the winding machinery, but did not think there was any danger; but Mason said he had
no recollection of being so told. The result of this inquiry was that the jury returned a
verdict of manslaughter against Francis Downing, the engineman, specially exonerating
Mr. Nock and Leedham and Mason, against whom previous juries had returned verdicts
of manslaughter. All four now await their trials at the ensuing March assizes, but the
contradictory verdicts of the juries, and still more the accident itself, shows the want in
this, as in very many cases, of better discipline, and especially of a more distinct vesting
of responsibility in particular persons.
It is clear that with the plain indications of danger which were manifest, and of which
the workmen themselves on one occasion had complained, that more effectual means
than merely "pecking up" the frame day by day should have been taken, to render
secure that on which the lives of so many persons were daily depending. The cases
being now sub judice, it is not desirable to say more as to this melancholy accident.
- 1864 Mines Inspectors Report, by James P. Baker, H.M. Inspector of Mines, Page: 106
- 1864 Mines Inspectors Report, by James P. Baker, H.M. Inspector of Mines, Page: 119, Accident Number: 77
If you are researching E. Caperrell (e.g. for family tree purposes) and you would
like to hear from others with the same interest then please complete
the details in the following form. We will show the information you provide
on this page so that you can be contacted.

Return

Return to Top