logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Donate to support the Museum
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

  Individual Details   Individual Details  
 


John Ellis

Age:  
Died:   26th Sep 1861
Accident:   26th Sep 1861
Born:  
Colliery:   South Mostyn
Company:   Adam Eyton
Occupation:   Collier
Notes:  
An explosion of gas
Buried:   [not known]
Category:  

Description

At the South Mostyn Colliery the mines were won and being worked by means of two pits or shafts, of the respective depths of 110 and 140 yards, and by two tunnels extending from the bottom of the latter upwards of 700 yards on the dip of the measures, from underneath the tideway of the River Dee. These tunnels, one of which was used as a return air-course only, had opened out several seams of coal in that distance, all of which had been exhausted to the level thereof and then abandoned; and recently they had been continued to an overlying seam, in which the deceased persons were employed when the explosion happened. The workings of this colliery, which are shown on the plan annexed, are, as they appear, so limited in extent, it seems difficult to understand how, if common appliances only had been used there with ordinary skill and attention, it were possible for a serious casualty to occur. The mines between the pits or shafts, which are about 135 yards apart, had been previously extracted, and the return air from the workings on the deep was conducted through that goaf, which is so intersected with faults as to render it difficult to keep an open road to the upcast shaft ; and the length and sectional area also of the horizontal tunnels offered considerable resistance to the ventilation, which was produced by an inadequate contrivance on the surface. That apparatus consisted of a fan 6 feet 8 inches in diameter and 2 feet wide, with vanes 2 feet deep, driven by a steam engine with an 8-inch cylinder and 2-feet stroke, and by the application of straps and pulleys, at the rate upon the average of about 300 revolutions per minute. As it had only been recently provided and suspended from, immediately after the explosion to the present time, in consequence of the colliery not having been hitherto re-opened, I have had no fair opportunity of testing its power, on which from experiments made at other places, and with a smaller fan, which was used in the same situation and under similar circumstances years ago, I fear little or no reliance could be safely placed. To the continuance of the last-mentioned fan I raised, on my first visit there, a strong objection ; and either from that or some other cause it was discontinued soon afterwards, when a furnace on the surface was substituted and used for some time.

Ascertaining upon my last inspection of the colliery, before the casualty occurred, that the tunnels were to be extended to another seam of coal, still further on the deep, that inflammable gas was quietly emitted, and that although the ventilation prevented any accumulation of gas, the return air was not sufficiently pure, while the margin between safety and danger would be thereby gradually lessened, I insisted upon all naked or open lights being prohibited, and upon the use of safety lamps only throughout all the underground workings, and caused the tunnels and air-courses to be very much enlarged in their sectional area, with a view of procuring temporarily additional protection for the workpeople ; but for the purpose of obtaining permanent relief, I pointed out by notice to the owners the risk that would be incurred by continuing operations below till such times as a new shaft had been sunk on the deep, and urged the importance of that being provided without delay.

In reply to these requirements there was not only no objection made, but on the contrary a satisfactory compliance therewith was frankly expressed, and in carrying out the two first there was no delay, neither was there any demur to the latter, which was intended to be done when the ground where it was proposed to sink had been proved, and for that operations were in progress.

I arrived at the colliery soon after the explosion occurred, before all the deceased persons were got out, and found a considerable quantity of highly inflammable gas within a few yards of the bottom of the downcast pit, which prevented further ingress. The return air-course had been closed by the explosion, and gas was issuing from the upcast pit through the fan. On the surface, where it fired vigorously in the lamp, I made several careful examinations of all the underground works into which I could enter, for the purpose of discovering, if it were possible, the cause that led to the explosion, or the source from which so much mischief had arisen, but in that (the colliery not having been re-opened) I completely failed.

The deceased were found lying about midway in the tunnel, dressed, and with their lamps all locked and perfect, and as it was the time for leaving off work it is supposed that as they were on their way to the pit they walked into the after damp produced by the explosion, which had most likely hastened their departure, but through which they could not pass while the power of moving remained and reason maintained its sway.

It was stated in evidence at the inquest upon the deceased that the north level in one of the mines had been recently passed through a fault and into another seam of coal called the "Dwrbog" mine, which the throw or break of the continuity of the strata had brought into that position, from which gas was freely emitted ; that the ventilation during the previous shift was good, and that the air-courses, which had been examined not long before, were then open and of proper dimensions. It was proved also by many trustworthy witnesses that they saw the shed which covered the fan on fire from twenty minutes to half an hour before they heard the report of the explosion, and that the flames thereof could be seen at a considerable distance.

The accuracy of the accompanying plan of the underground works was proved by the resident manager of the colliery, Mr. John Williams, who described the effective power of the fan, on which he had with great, though evidently too much confidence relied, as being superior to any other means for producing ventilation that under the peculiar circumstances of the case could be applied. But he admitted, upon cross-examination, that it had only been at work a few weeks, and was provided in consequence of the return air, which had become vitiated, having to pass over the furnace then in use, which on one occasion he had seen flaming above the top of the chimney on the surface.

It was also stated in the evidence of others that a short time before the shed took fire the strap by which the steam-engine imparted motion to the fan broke, and that the fan lamp was thereby suspended while the necessary repair was completed, during which, although the day was beginning to dawn, a safety lamp was used for that purpose.

If these statements are entitled to belief, there can be no better proof than they supply that then and for some weeks prior to the explosion the colliery had been in a critical state, and that the preparations for producing ventilation had reached the utmost limit. But as it may be argued that it had been satisfactorily proved to be capable of affording adequate safety below, and that if the strap had not given way the casualty would not have happened, such arguments only show more clearly the naked absurdity of depending upon one fragile piece of mechanism for the ventilation of a complicated and dangerous colliery, in which explosive gas is frequently and suddenly evolved. There may, however, be places in which an apparatus of that description could be applied ; but in every instance a duplicate should be provided, and so arranged that if one should happen to fail the other could be immediately set to work.

From the evidence thus given and from several personal inspections of the underground works prior to and after the explosion, I have formed the following opinion, which is based upon the most natural conclusion that can be drawn, after all the circumstances are known and maturely considered.

As the ventilation would almost cease with the last revolution of the fan, inflammable gas would then rapidly accumulate throughout the workings, which might cause the poor fellows to leave off work a little before the usual time of doing so. The engine driver stated also that upon again starting the fan it was driven at an increased and unusual speed, with the object of recovering the ground that had been lost, until he perceived the premises on fire ; it is evident, therefore, that the accumulated gas would be passed through the fan immediately after it was set in motion, and that from the fact of the fire having been seen so long before the explosion was heard, that it was ignited at or near the fan on the surface, either by an open light or by the shaft or axle of the fan having become heated to such an extent as to set the wood-work around it on fire, and that it continued to burn until it came in contact with an explosive mixture of gas in the tunnel or workings below.

None of the deceased were burnt; and as there were no other persons in the mine when the occurrence happened, to one or other of the above-mentioned causes the ignition of the gas must be attributed, and as the appearance of the fan shaft contributed no evidence in support of the latter, my first impression, that it was caused by the former, still remains unshaken.

The circumstances attending this casualty are such as to give rise to the most serious considerations, while they show in language stronger than can be written the superiority of the furnace over the fan where one fan only has been provided, and that in trusting to one only in this case an irretrievable error was committed. Where an underground furnace is properly constructed and of sufficient power, by the heat which the shaft would acquire ventilation would be continued for some time even after the fire was subdued ; but in the case of other appliances, it ceases when their operation becomes suspended. As I may have to refer to this question on a future occasion, when I have availed myself of the permission which has been granted to me to investigate the useful effect of such ventilating machines in other places, I have only further to observe, that the jury found, "The deceased persons came by their death accidentally and by misfortune, and not otherwise."


Memorial: 1861 South Mostyn Colliery Disaster

Memorial Image


Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
28 Sep 1861  Frightful Colliery Accident, South Mostyn, Flintshire (North Wales Chronicle)
05 Oct 1861  Epitome Of News (Berwick Journal)

Sources
  • 1861 Mines Inspectors Report, by Peter Higson, H.M. Inspector of Mines, Page: 42
  • 1861 Mines Inspectors Report, by Peter Higson, H.M. Inspector of Mines, Page: 49, Accident Number: 55

Researchers

If you are researching John Ellis (e.g. for family tree purposes) and you would like to hear from others with the same interest then please complete the details in the following form. We will show the information you provide on this page so that you can be contacted.

What is your name?
What is your contact email address?
What is your research interest?

 

Return Return   Return Return to Top

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 30 Apr 2023

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print