I have not heard of any proceedings having been taken against any of the workpersons by owners, agents, or managers for breaches of the Act or Special Rules, and the only occasion on which I have found it necessary to ask your permission to prosecute was in the case of Mr. James Harper, the agent of the Winder Gill Iron Ore Mine, Winder, Cumberland, for a breach of General Rule 7, in not having the top of a working shaft properly fenced. Although I considered it my duty to bring the case to your notice, the breach of the rule was not of a flagrant nature, and was due more to oversight than to any other cause, for as the defendant said, he knew the back of the shaft was not fenced, but it never occurred to him that it should be so protected, as no one but the top hand had any right to go there. He was aware, however, that other men had been seen there, and that should have put him on his guard. Unfortunately, one of the men who was going to the back of the shaft, because it was drier, to get his breakfast, tripped over a piece of timber and fell down the pit.
The case was heard at the Whitehaven Petty Sessions, on August 30th, before H. Fox, Esq. (in the chair), J. N. Dickinson, Esq., J. D. Watson, Esq., and W. H. Watson, Esq., and after the Bench had retired to consider their decision, the Chairman said they were agreed that the shaft was not properly fenced and that there must be a conviction. They inflicted a penalty of £5.
Source: 1894 Mines Inspectors Report (C 7667), Newcastle District (No. 3) by J. L. Hedley, H.M. Inspector of Mines