At Trimdon Grange Colliery, Durham, while one cage was standing on the saddle beams at the pit bottom and the top deck was being loaded with tubs, one of the guide ropes fell down the shaft. It was found that this guide rope had broken just below the clamps in the headgear and that an adjacent guide rope was also broken near the bottom where it passed through the saddle beams. The guide ropes were loaded in pairs and there seems little doubt that the guide rope which fractured at the saddle beams gave way first thus throwing the whole of the tension weight, about 9 tons, suddenly on the other guide rope and causing it to fracture in the headgear. As I pointed out in my report last year, most cases of fractures of guide ropes occur at or near the attachment in the headgear or where the rope passes through a bunton, eye or D clamp in the shaft bottom to prevent oscillation. The parts outside the travel of the cage should be galvanised or protected by tar or paint. Further, there seems no real advantage in weighting the guide ropes in pairs. The best practice is to load all the guide ropes with slightly different loads so that their periods of oscillation may be different.
In both of the above occurrences it was highly probable that if the statutory examination of the guides had been as thorough as it should have been defects would have been discovered and suitable steps taken to prevent accident.
Source: 1928 Mines Inspectors Report