Another electrical accident containing dangerous possibilities took place inbye in the Low Main Seam of the North Biddick Colliery, Durham. A double wire armoured 3-core cable, carrying a 500 volt alternating current, served a small pump in one of the districts. The circuit was protected near the shaft bottom by an overload, trip switch. A deputy going along the road saw flashes from the cable and lie promptly telephoned to the shaft for the current to be cut off, and sent for the electrician. It was found on examination that the cable had been punctured with blows from a sharp tool such as a pick. Fortunately there was neither gas nor coal-dust about; but, at the same time, there was plenty of wood, which might have taken lire had the accident not been detected in time. Mr. Nelson, Electrical Inspector of Mines, investigated the occurrence, and reported: "Examination showed the cable to be punctured, apparently by blows from a sharp tool such as a pick. The overload trip switch which was supposed to protect the circuit did not act. The reason the overload trip did not act is because such protection is in no way sensitive. The leakage current has to exceed the value at which the overload trip is set to operate before the latter is called into action. That is to say, the leakage current must first exceed the working current by perhaps 100 per cent. Clearly a leakage of any value up to this overload value might produce open sparking indefinitely with only such protection as was provided at this colliery, and, it may be added, with only such protection as is usually provided below ground in mines. The contingency of a cable damaged by a pick or a nail, or by a fall of stone, may be held to be remote, but it cannot be ignored in all cases. The remedy, however, is to provide leakage cut-out protection which is called into action immediately any portion of the current, it may be a small portion, leaves the conductors provided for it to return to the generator by some other path — for example by the cable armouring or more directly via earth. When such a leakage occurs there is a "fault" on the circuit and the balance which normally exists at every instant between the current which enters and that which leaves the conductors of a healthy circuit is disturbed. Leakage cut-outs are brought into action by such disturbances of balance only, and they may be set to operate with any degree of sensitiveness, if it is desired to cut off the pressure from a circuit quickly should a fault occur — for example in the event of a fall of stone on a cable in an atmosphere charged with coal dust — the advantage which a leakage out-out confers over an overload cut-out is at once clear. There can be no doubt that the protection of circuits below ground by this leakage method will become the established practice in the near future."
Source: 1914 Mines Inspectors Report (Cd 8023)