An overwind occurred at Hetton Colliery, Durham.
The downcast shaft is 112 and 130 fathoms deep to the main coal and low main seams respectively. It is fitted with double-decked cages, which run in rail guides. The engine is of the ordinary horizontal twin cylinder type and is fitted with Whitmore post brakes. A Whitmore overwind preventer and Ormerod detaching hooks are also installed.
Just before the occurrence the west side cage was standing at the main coal level, the other consequently being 18 fathoms from the surface. The engineman was asked to bring the west side cage to the surface, but he, evidently mistaking the position of his reversing lever, brought the other cage up. He had given the engine full steam and the cage was in consequence brought to the surface at an excessive speed. The overwind preventer failed to stop the engine in time and the cage was taken into the headgear. The detaching hook acted properly and the cage was suspended, no damage being done.
Tests of the overwind preventer were made on the same day and these gave satisfactory results. It was decided, however, to make more tests on the 13th, the pit then being idle. These tests gave satisfactory results except the last one. On this occasion the apparatus failed to stop the engine in time and the cage travelled up into the headgear. The detaching hook again acted properly but the cage dropped back on to the chains. This broke the shackle on the hook and the cage fell back down the shaft.
The Whitmore gear has three settings. One controls the speed during the wind, the second is to prevent an overwind or start in the wrong direction, and the third is to control the speed during the last three revolutions of the drum. The failures referred to above were failures of this third setting and were apparently due to the inertia of moving parts preventing a cam from engaging with certain teeth properly in a very short interval of time. This was overcome by cutting a small slot in the end of a lever instead of a circular hole. This slot allowed a certain amount of play and gave the short interval of time necessary for the cam to engage with the teeth properly. This slight alteration has worked well and no difficulty has been experienced, although tested frequently.
Colliery managers will be well advised seriously to consider the question of installing means of preventing a cage falling back the full length of the cage chains in the event of an overwind and the operation of the detaching hook. This can be done by the provision of keps in the headgear.
The above experience proves the necessity of always maintaining an overwind preventer in the most efficient state and taking steps to prove that it is in the best possible working order.
Source: 1925 Mines Inspectors Report