At Hylton Colliery, Durham, while the cages were stationary in the shaft one of the eight guide ropes, which had been in service 30 years, broke at a weld 30 fathoms from the top of the shaft, 293 fathoms deep, and in falling down the shaft struck one of the other guide ropes and caused it to fracture at a part that was badly worn adjacent to the saddle beams in the shaft bottom. I consider it unwise to use welded guide ropes. In this case the whole of the guide ropes were replaced by new ones as quickly as possible.
In both of the above occurrences it was highly probable that if the statutory examination of the guides had been as thorough as it should have been defects would have been discovered and suitable steps taken to prevent accident.
Source: 1928 Mines Inspectors Report