There were six cases where winding engine drum shafts broke during the year, and all connected with engines which had been in use for many years. In one case at Dipton Colliery, Durham, the winding engine was an old-fashioned single vertical cylinder, 36 inches diameter, and 5-feet stroke with a 16-feet diameter drum, and 22-feet diameter flywheel overhead. The steam pipes were 20 yards in length to the engine, then had a vertical drop of 6 feet to the bottom of the valve chest. After the engine had been standing for some hours the engineman was preparing to wind water, and, he said, he admitted steam to one side of the piston and before the stroke was completed opened the exhaust to allow any water there might be to blow through. He asserted that he did this for three or four strokes, when he felt as if there were a rush of water on to the top side of the piston; and just as the top of the stroke was reached the main shaft broke, causing the large vertical connecting rod and crank to fall back. The winder had a narrow escape. The accident was doubtless due to a sudden flow of water into the cylinder just at the time when the stroke was nearing completion. The shaft was a square one, and was 11 inches diameter at the journals; it broke close to the journal on the crank side. A large portion of the fracture was crystalline, and from its general appearance there had been an old flaw near the outside. Really only a small portion of the shaft had any strength.
Source: 1914 Mines Inspectors Report (Cd 8023)