Museum Entrance Museum Entrance
Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
Colliery Guardian
Colliery Guardian - Main Index
Colliery Guardian - Subject Index
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Title Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Title
 
Masthead
August 29, 1963

Mining Witherite in North-West Durham

By J. H. Ashburn, A.M.I.M.E., Assoc.I.Min.E., Certified Mine Surveyor, Sunderland Technical College

Barium carbonate, BaCo3, occurs naturally as witherite, an insoluble white mineral with a specific gravity of 4.3 and hardness 3.5. Associated with the deposits are barium sulphate ("barytes" or "heavy spar"), BaSo4, of specific gravity 4.0; galena (sulphides of lead); and much pyrites (FeS).

The commercial value of witherite is shown by the considerable uses that it has in the form of the various barium salts, which can be obtained from the carbonate as can be seen from Fig. 1.

Barytes, although not mined in the area to be described, has the property of absorbing radiation and is used extensively in the screening of X-rays, nuclear reactors, etc.

Occurrence and Formation

The mineral was located near the village of Burnhope in North-West Durham, approximately 12 miles south of Newcastle upon Tyne (see Fig. 2).

It was proved in five veins, each formed in adjacent fault planes running east to west. At the western extremity the faults join together to give a downthrow of 240 ft. to the north, and they diverge to the east into the three main deposits (see Fig. 3).

The fault to the south, commonly known as the "Spar Dyke," has a downthrow of 120 ft. to the north, and although considered to be the "mother lode," the west development of this vein showed only small quantities of witherite, together with much fault breccia. The next important vein occurred to the north in a fault of 30 ft. downthrow and was known as the South-East vein which was of considerable economic value. The northerly fault has a downthrow of 60 ft. to the north. In this fault plane was situated the mine shaft and the mineral was first exploited from this area.

The thickness of the witherite varied greatly from minute hair veins in the fault breccia up to about 12 ft. of mineral filling the fault plane. An exceptional thickness of 22 ft. occurred at the junction of the veins and was known as the "Bonanza" area which extended for about 100 ft. in length. The inclination of these veins varied from 75 deg. to 80 deg.

At the upper extremities of the deposits a change occurred in the mineral and it was found that "sulphating" had taken place and although there was no clear dividing line the change occurred at a depth of about 250 ft. below the surface and tended to follow the surface configuration. Above this line was barytes and below it lay the witherite.

The main veins were very irregular and contained considerable areas of barren ground. Owing to the nature of the veins, prospecting was a costly item; the only way was to forge ahead with the development headings in order to ascertain the ground.

Occasionally cavities were found of considerable size, and the biggest one, on the main haulage level (4A), contained water. The depth of this cavity could not be ascertained and several days of continual dumping of debris was required before a suitable floor was obtained for the working to proceed. In another case, a cavity found in the upper levels was 20 ft. long, 10 ft. high and 3 ft. 6 in. wide.

At the lower workable extremities of the veins the horizon of the Brockwell seam (S) was found to be the "farewell" level. Only minute traces of witherite have been located at any lower depths, although exploration has taken place to below the Victoria and Marshall Green seams (see Fig. 4). At the Brockwell seam (S) horizon, there occurred a ¾ in. thick vein of galena, but, being of limited extent, this was of no economic value.

Many theories have been put forward with regard to the formation of these veins, and they are regarded as being hypabyssal in origin, although the relative absence of any continuity below the "farewell" horizon may be significant when the means of intrusion is considered. Another theory has been expressed as the dissolution of the mineral in water and then the subsequent crystallisation. As already stated, witherite is insoluble in water under normal conditions (2.4 mgrm. per ltr.), hence under what conditions dissolution took place, one cannot visualise. Whatever the method of formation, the intergrown crystal structures lining the walls of cavities were indeed remarkable.

History

The discovery of the vein was made in the Hutton seam (L) workings of the Morrison North Pit about the year 1928. At first the economic importance of this substance was not realised, and owing to the nature of the ground the workings were stowed up. Some time later when the value of the mineral was realised, steps were taken to reopen the stowed roadways and to commence working the vein. Levels were driven in the vein to the east and west, with raises (rectangular drivages upwards in the vein) driven to a distance of 30 ft. where a new level (A level) was formed. This sequence was repeated with raises 100 ft. apart along the levels until D level was reached 120 ft. above the original Hutton level, where it was found that "sulphating" had occurred.

At this stage, exploration was in progress from the Hutton level by a main winze, a 10 ft. by 6 ft. drivage downwards in the vein for a distance of 60 ft. to form a new level (3 level), then a further 30 ft. to 3A level horizon, where further workings took place.

This sequence of development was continued by another winze (1 east winze) driven 8 ft. by 6 ft. downwards forming new levels, 4 level at 60 ft., then 4A level 30 ft. below 4 level, and so on until the Brockwell or "farewell" horizon was reached at the 5A level. It is perhaps suitable to mention at this point the primitive method of haulage adopted during this initial work. A small hoppit was filled at the lower levels and then raised up 1 east winze by means of a compressed air hauler to 3A level. The hoppit was then lowered on to a tram and the tram manhandled along 3A level to the bottom of the main winze. The hoppit was then lifted by another compressed air hauler to the Hutton level, where it was emptied into a tub, and then transported by pony haulage to join up with the Morrison North Pit haulage system.

Several Ponies Die

Around this time, an unfortunate incident occurred; several ponies used for underground haulage were found dead in the underground stables after eating fodder which had been transported in the same tubs as had been used for transporting the mineral. Steps were then taken to avoid any recurrence of this type of accident.

The next step in the development of the mine was the decision to drive a steeply inclined main shaft to the surface. This was accomplished by driving downwards at 15 ft. by 6 ft. at an inclination of 85 deg. (not in the vein) from the Hutton level to the lower 4A level. This shaft was then driven upwards from the Hutton level to the surface. While driving upwards, the lower part of the shaft was used to lift the mineral from the lower levels by two compressed air haulers to the Hutton level, the shaft being divided into two hoppit compartments, each 6 ft. wide, and a 3 ft. wide travelling compartment utilising 12 ft. ladders and platforms.

The shaft in progressing upwards from the Hutton level met with serious difficulties between C and D levels, where intersection with the vein took place, and working was temporarily abandoned. Drivage was eventually resumed from the surface downwards, and the shaft holing took place sometime in 1944.

Fatal Accident

In order to provide adequate travelling facilities and ventilation, a rise was driven at approximately 1 in 1 from the Hutton level to the surface. It was during this drivage that the only fatal accident to happen at this mine took place. It occurred when a workman was trapped by the legs when fine sugarlike witherite fell from the face of the rising drive, and he was eventually buried by the mineral and died from asphyxia. When the rising drive reached the surface a ventilating fan was installed together with a winder, gantry and hopper at the shaft. Winding of the mineral to the surface was then commenced using a large shaft hoppit riding on wooden guides having a concave surface.

The ingress and egress to the mine at this time was by means of 250 steps down the 1 in 1 drive to the Hutton level and then by 35 12 ft. ladders down the travelling compartment of the main shaft. Man-riding in the shaft was prohibited, except for examination or in the case of an accident, when the specially designed shaft stretcher was attached to the hook of the winding rope, the casualty being firmly strapped to the stretcher, and the stretcher then hauled to the surface.

From the shaft the now established haulage level (4A) was being extended west, and an area of barren ground was being negotiated when a decision was made to close the mine. It was thought that the vein had petered out, but after another 50 yd. of drivage the "Bonanza" area was located. With 22 ft. of high grade witherite in this area the future again looked bright and it was here that the new veins were found to have joined the working vein.

Exploitation of the further veins was by means of cross-measure drifts from the main haulage level. The working of the vein thus continued until about 1956 when the veins thinned. After many exploratory attempts to ascertain further deposits by use of inclined cored boreholes, gravimetric geophysical prospecting, and exploratory shafts and levels, the mine was finally closed in July 1958. In addition to the uneconomical resources this was also partly due to the stringent regulations now coming into force under the Mines and Quarries Act 1954, which repealed the previous Metalliferous Mines Acts

Working Development

A simple analogy for the method of development adopted in this type of mining would be to visualise normal bord and pillar coal working on a vertical plane

The levels proceeded at intervals of 30 ft. (see Fig. 5) and were connected by raises or winzes, normally 8 ft. by 6 ft. wide, at a distance of 100 ft. apart, forming the pillars of mineral. The levels followed the vein and varied in width according to the distance between the "hanging" wall and the "foot" wall, but a minimum width of 5 ft. was normally adopted.

In the drivage of the raises, a simple safety precaution was observed; at each level the raise was offset the width of the raise (8 ft ). This ensured that any fall of either mineral or a person would be limited to 30 ft. and possible fatalities avoided.

Method of Extraction

At this mine, there were two methods used:

(1) Overhand stoping.

(2) Underhand stoping.

In overhand stoping, the mineral was worked upwards in "stopes" or "lifts," and use was made of gravitation in transporting the mineral to the haulage level below.

On the lower level, from which the "stope" was to be extracted, breaking in was commenced at a raise and a 6 ft. "leading" stope was extracted by drilling and firing off the solid, allowing the mineral to fall through the arched girders of the level. An artificial floor of timber was then made on the top of the arched girders up to the new face of the stope. Supports were set and the fallen mineral filled into tubs, The tubs were then transported by hand to a previously constructed chute and emptied, the mineral then gravitated to the main haulage level below.

This sequence of operations was repeated until the leading stope had been extracted to the next raise (i.e. 100 ft. length of stope extracted). This 6 ft. void was then solidly packed to a height of 4 ft. with debris from nearby stone drivages or from stone drifts driven in order to provide the packing material required. This was known as "matting," to give a suitable floor for the extraction of the second stope, and leaving a 2 ft. space to facilitate ventilation.

The second stope was extracted to 4 ft. above the ventilation space (i.e. 6 ft. from the artificial floor), in a similar manner to the leading stope extraction and the "matting" again carried out to a height of 4 ft.

This procedure was repeated for each successive stope until only the final 4 ft. stope remained below the upper level. This stope was then extracted by the underhand method.

In the underhand method, the space below the underhand stope was solidly packed up to the mineral and work commenced from the upper level by digging into the mineral floor and extracting a 6 ft. length of stope, the workmen being protected by 12 ft. baulks or "stringers" similar to the forepoling used in coal mining, except that they were supported by props at both front and rear ends. It is obvious that when a 6 ft. length of underhand had been removed, the rear supports would be set on the final "matting," thus adequate sole-pieces, 2 ft. in length, were required. The "stringers" were then moved forward 6 ft. and another 6 ft. length of stope extracted. This procedure was repeated until the whole of the underhand had been removed.

Advantages of the overhand stoping method were found to be:

(1) Broken mineral fell away from the face.

(2) Gravitation assisted transport of the mineral.

(3) Face and hanging wall were accessible for examination.

(4) Misfires were more easily detected.

(5) The chute acted as a bunker in case of stoppages.

In extraction of the mineral, the stope faces were drilled using Ingersoll-Rand machines mounted on jack-legs. Owing to the varying nature of the mineral, there was no set pattern of drilling, and it was found by experience that worm drills were essential as the plain drills were difficult to extract from the holes.

Blasting was carried out by means of Nitrox explosive and six-shot exploders of the DavisDerby type, and here again it is difficult to give any indication of the charges of explosive used. In the stone drifts, gelignite explosives were utilised as the strata was fairly hard.

Transport

From the face, transport of the mineral was carried out using small open-ended tubs (3 ft. by 2 ft. 3 in. by 1 ft. 6 in.), having a steel heck-board at one end. These tubs were manhandled to the chutes and emptied. In these bunker chutes the mineral gravitated to the lower levels, and as these chutes were originally offset at each level, they required a brick or wooden deflecting platform which also assisted in retarding the mineral during its fall.

In converting raises to bunker chutes, safety precautions were again observed by complete enclosure with brick walling, except for the inspection doors which opened into the adjacent ladder way, and the wooden doors covering the top of the chute.

The bottoms of the bunker chutes were situated on the haulage levels and sets of 10 to 12 tubs were filled from a chute and hauled to the shaft sidings by a main and tail system of haulage. It is to be appreciated that the main haulage level followed the course of the vein, and thus considerable difficulty was encountered in siting the ropes by means of deflecting sheaves or rubbing sheaves.

At the shaft bottom, the tubs gravitated to a hopper, or ore-bin, where they were emptied and then manhandled back to the empty side track. From the ore-bin, the mineral was filled into the large shaft hoppit which was hauled up the shaft riding on the concave wooden guides. On reaching the surface, large wood doors closed over the shaft in order to allow a normal sized mine tub to be placed in position to collect the mineral from the hoppit. The tub was then hauled manually along the gantry to a tippler and hopper. From the hopper, road transport was utilised in carrying the mineral to the treatment plant situated about two miles away from the mine at the Morrison North Pit.

Ventilation

This was not such a great problem as it would at first appear in mining of this type. The ventilating system gave a reasonably adequate airflow throughout the workings of the mine, considering that not only were the levels and the workings to be ventilated but also stone drivages for the three veins.

The ventilation system was mainly ascensional, and the air entered the mine by the main shaft, circulated the workings in a general upwards direction and returned to the fan via the upper 3 level and the rising drive.

Considerable use was made of ventilation by auxiliary fans, especially in the exploratory drifts and levels, and also numerous ventilation doors were required in the cross-measure drifts.

Output and Manpower

The mine commenced production in 1932 with 2,000 tons of mineral mined for that year. The production increased to 8,000 tons in 1940, 11,600 tons in 1946, and from 1946 to 1958 the output varied from 10,000 tons to 16,000 tons per annum. The total output from 1932 to 1958 was 233,579 tons.

During the latter years of the life of the mine, there was between 150 to 200 men employed.

Surveying and Plans

In this type of mining, extensive use is made of the mining theodolite and the Mabon dial, together with the requisite ancillary equipment. For the primary surveys, the theodolite was always used, but for secondary surveys the Mabon dial proved very satisfactory.

This type of dial had two fixed verniers diametrically opposed and reading to 1 min. of arc; the revolving compass box was graduated anti-clockwise in degrees and had two sighting vanes attached. On one of these vanes, in addition to the normal peephole sights, there were two small hinged sights which could be raised to stand out perpendicular to the vane. These sights are called Gemmell sights and they were used in conjunction with a graduated quadrant at the base of the vane for measuring angles of inclination.

Along the working levels surveying was much the same as in normal coal mining, but when carrying the survey lines up or down raises to other levels use was made of wooden platforms erected within the raise. On the occasion where a reasonably vertical raise was met with, two wires were hung in the raise and the survey line transferred to another horizon by means of the Weisbach triangle method of correlation.

With all the surveying methods utilised, great care was necessary owing to the large-scale plans used. The mine plans were basically on a scale of 40 ft. to 1 in., with a plan showing the veins, and a section of each working vein. A secondary set of plans, similar in style to the mine plans, were on a scale of 100 ft. to 1 in.

The construction of these large-scale plans was necessary because of the difficulty in locating the various levels and also in distinguishing any particular horizon. The sectional drawings were a major problem, and two alternative styles were available;

(a) A section drawn on the plane of the vein giving an accurate determination of mineral tonnage but giving incorrect vertical distances, or

(b) A vertical section showing an elevation of the vein with correct vertical intervals between horizons, but an incorrect area in determination of mineral tonnage.

In this case the vertical section was used, as the high inclination of the deposits introduced only a slight error in the tonnages calculated, whereas the vertical intervals were accurate and the horizons were shown in the correct relation to the mine datum (10,000 ft. B.O.D.).

With mineral deposits having an inclination of less magnitude, it may be advisable to have a vertical section, together with secondary sections on the plane of the vein for the determination of mineral tonnages and also for any distances required on the full dip of the vein.

Taking into account the various problems associated with this mine, it was essential that the utmost care be taken in all aspects of surveying, levelling, construction of plans and the plotting of surveys. The staff engaged in these duties required to have an intimate knowledge of the mine and its workings in order to avoid serious errors.

Prospecting

As has already been stated, exploration and prospecting in this type of occurrence involve high capital outlay; trial and error together with perseverance are great factors.

During the period at which considerable prospecting was carried out (1956 to 1958) the following methods were utilised:

(1) Exploratory winnings were driven in the fault planes following minute hair veins — always in the hope of locating another "Bonanza." These winnings involved serious ventilation problems and auxiliary fans played a major role.

(2) Using coring tools, inclined boreholes were drilled to intersect the veins at various horizons. One asset in this aspect was the advantageous use made of the Tro-Pari borehole surveying instrument. This is one of the more recent developments in borehole surveying and this instrument gives the inclination and magnetic bearing of an inclined hole with comparatively accurate results, and, together with the simplicity of operation the instrument has indeed made its mark in this field.

The core recovery in these boreholes was not very satisfactory in the area of the mineral and fault breccia, and it was exceedingly difficult to obtain even 30 per cent. of any material within the fault plane.

(3) A grid system was accurately laid out on the surface over the veins and a gravimetrical geophysical survey carried out. Readings on the gravimeter were taken at each grid intersection over the area. These readings were then examined and interpreted by the specialist firm employed but no information of any value resulted.

(4) At a location several miles from the veins, where ancient drift mines had been worked for barytes, an exploratory shaft was sunk to a depth of 110 ft. From this shaft, levels were driven to prove the vein, but no mineral sections of any value were found.

Dressing and Marketing

The run of the mine mineral was prepared for the market at a treatment plant some two miles from the mine location. The mineral was first of all screened to a size of -6 in., and then washed and graded into the varying sizes (nuts, lump, peas and fines). The foreign material present in the witherite (chiefly carbonaceous matter from the adjacent strata) was removed first by manual picking and later by a form of gravity separation. The washed witherite was then dried in two centrifugal driers and then stored to await delivery to the chloride plant. At this plant, the witherite was treated with hydrochloric acid to obtain liquid barium chloride to facilitate long-distance transport. High-grade pulverised witherite produced at the treatment plant was transported loose or in bags.

The witherite passing through in the various grades had above 90 per cent. purity, and gave about 70 per cent. recovery on the crude mineral.

The main markets served were the U.S.A. and Belgium.

Conclusion

The life of the metalliferous mine described has indeed been an episode in the history of mining in the Durham Area. From the first production in 1932 to the closure in 1958, the mine has produced between 6,000 tons and 16,000 tons of high grade witherite per annum. Considering the fact that at that time the production of witherite throughout the world was only about 20,000 tons to 25,000 tons per annum, then with this mine at Burnhope, Co. Durham, together with a similar mine at Settlingstones near Hexham, Northumberland, the majority of the world's witherite production was concentrated in the north-east of England.

Geologically, this deposit was rare; essentially it consisted of metalliferous veins, probably of hypabyssal origin, situated in coal measure strata and surrounded by coal workings. The purity of the deposit was exceptional, as was the economic value, and only at the points of contact of the veins with the coal seams was there any infiltration of carbonaceous material into the mineral.

The probability of further occurrences in this area may be high, as traces of witherite and barytes have been located over a wide area in the locality. The possibility of locating any further veins is at this time remote owing to the high cost of prospecting and the scarcity of local coal mine workings as a means of access. Nevertheless there is the possibility that at some future time workable veins may again be found and be of the same value as those described.

Acknowledgments

The author is greatly indebted to M. Hill, a "Workman extraordinary," who was employed at the mine over the greater part of its life; he gave great assistance in the preparation of this paper.

Also the assistance given by the staff of the National Coal Board, Durham Division, No. 6 Area (now No. 5 Area), and the surveying staff of "C" Group of this Area.

Finally, thanks are due to members of the staff of Sunderland Technical College, Mining Department, whose assistance and constructive criticism were of utmost importance in the layout of the paper.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print