Investing In Students
"We can well be satisfied with a system of university education which, through the use of external examiners, secures a common standard for all first degrees in all British universities, and an 85 per cent. chance that a student will reach this common standard. The worm which gnaws at our satisfaction is that we have worked out a successful solution to this problem of quality control at the expense of a far greater problem which we have shirked: the problem of how to invest efficiently in the rest of our resources of talent. While our wastage rate in universities is commendably low, we cannot forget the heavy casualties among young people who do not get full-time higher education and who try to qualify themselves through night classes, day release and correspondence courses."
Among the so-called "heavy casualties" who strive after the undisputed benefits of higher education are large numbers of mining, electrical and mechanical engineering students who attend nearly 50 mining and technical colleges throughout Britain. In their respective categories it is usually the Class 1 certificate that presents the challenge; its possession, it is naturally assumed, virtually ensures future security and status, and who is to dispute the value of two such features of respectable society. But in sponsoring courses for students, does such an aim reflect the vision of course designers?
Part-time education has a number of inherent disadvantages when compared with that in universities and, in fact, full-time diploma courses at technical colleges. The limitations of technical college education is not peculiar to those courses in mining engineering, but surely more can be done with the backing of a giant organisation such as the National Coal Board to close this well-defined gap between the end product of these two educational institutions.
The gap mentioned is not an academic one. It is one of attitude and approach to the industry. One is more likely to produce and convert imaginative ideas into practical reality when opportunities provide the most advanced knowledge, access to the latest technical developments and an environment which encourages the exchange of views and opinions. This a university provides, while in general, technical colleges valiantly strive to teach the facts essential to pass examinations. Tremendous work has been done by the staff of these colleges in the formation of various societies, organising visits, cultural pursuits, and in general helping students feel a closer affinity between themselves and the college.
With the allocation of more money to technical colleges a great deal more can be done. Inter-Divisional visits, which are usually organised for the benefit of diploma students, could be extended to include those taking other courses. In the same way the Coal Board establishments might open their doors more frequently. Taking this further, a link might be formed between the mining students and the machinery manufacturer. With few exceptions the only relationship between them now is a brochure sent to the student on request.
The mining student, if he is to serve the industry well, must be kept in constant touch, through personal experience, with its most recent technical developments. When this is done he will have a base from which to advance the techniques of the present and what is just as important, have a wider appreciation of the industry's organisation and its problems.
Our opening paragraph is taken from Sir Eric Ashby's presidential address delivered to the British Association for the Advancement of Science at Aberdeen yesterday (Wednesday). The address was entitled "Investment in Man." It might well provide a motto for this industry, where its wise application should in the near future convert that much publicised plateau of mechanised mining into a mere stepping-stone.