Museum Entrance Museum Entrance
Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
Colliery Guardian
Colliery Guardian - Main Index
Colliery Guardian - Subject Index
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Title Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Title
 
Masthead
February 5, 1932

Dust Prevention In The Coal Industry.

Discussion on Prof. LYLE CUMMINS' paper on "The Need of Dust Prevention Measures in the Coal Industry" (see Colliery Guardian, December 18, 1931, p. 2033) was continued at the South Wales Institute of Engineers, at Cardiff, on January 20, when Mr. CLARENCE A. SEYLER (Swansea) presided.

The Work of the Engineer.

Capt. P. S. HAY (H.M. Mines Department, London) recalled that in 1930 the Mines Department appointed to the staff of the inspectorate an engineer to deal specifically with the question of dust prevention. Since that date roughly 150 investigations had been carried out, principally in coal mines, and these had already resulted in a marked improvement in conditions and, in addition, the adoption in large numbers of various devices for the suppression of dust.

As regards the various factors in dust prevention, the present position of their development is as follows :— (a) Altogether there are between 500 and 600 dust traps of different makes in operation throughout the country; they are certainly not universal, but he thought Prof. Cummins would be surprised at the number that were actually working at present. Reference might also be made under this heading to the work which is being done on the evolution of simple and efficient dust extraction plants for surface screens and tipplers, particularly at anthracite collieries; also underground at gate-end loading points from conveyors. (b) Water-fed drills of numerous types and makes, by means of which the dust produced was immediately converted to sludge by water passing, under pressure, through a hollow drill steel. There was another appliance, called the "Minimax" foam apparatus which would shortly be submitted to for approval, and from tests he had carried out it appeared to be extraordinarily efficient. (c) Regarding respirators or masks, the position was not so satisfactory. A large number of these appliances was available, but the majority of them were entirely inefficient, and useless. A recent development was the bag respirator, evolved by an American firm, of which large numbers were in use by underground workers, who had, in the majority, adopted them with unusual enthusiasm. Reference might be made to the work at present being carried out in the development of the ideal dust respirator. The Research Department had been investigating the problem for 18 months, and last week he saw the first model ideal respirator, which certainly was very efficient and comfortable. It had a filtering efficiency of approximately 80 per cent., with a breathing resistance of ½ in water gauge, and weighed 4 ox. These extraordinary results had been produced by an entirely new filtering medium. This matter was also receiving the close attention of a prominent firm dealing with mine safety apparatus in this country and they had, during the past few weeks, developed two dust. respirators of an entirely novel type. (d) Regarding ventilation, as a result of the close attention devoted to this question by the mines inspectorate, a definite improvement can be reported, particularly in dead-ends and confined spaces underground. All inspectors now used instruments for determining dangerous dust concentration in the atmosphere. Efficient appliances for auxiliary ventilation had already been evolved and were in use or in course of development by manufacturing firms and practical mining men.

From the foregoing it would he appreciated that the engineer and inspector were doing their fair share, considering the meagre information at their disposal. As Dr. Cummins pointed out, it was essential that the engineer and the medical man should work hand in hand. But in order that the engineer might make still more rapid progress it was essential that he should be provided with more definite data by the medical expert. The information required was :—

(1) What are the rocks or other minerals the dust of which is harmful to breathe? (2) What is considered to be the safe limit of concentration in the atmosphere and the maximum size of particles of such dusts? (3) In the case of rocks which contain free silica," what is the maximum free silica of such rocks the dust of which can be breathed without harmful effects?

Dr. Fisher's Assurance.

Dr. SYDNEY W. FISHER, M.D. (H.M. Medical Inspector of Mines) said his object in taking part in the discussion was to allay any uneasiness that might exist in the minds of colliers owing to the general use made by Prof. Lyle Cummins of the term "coal miner." When one spoke of silicosis of the lungs of a coal miner one had in mind that process whereby the lungs are changing, or have changed, from the voluminous, spongy, freely movable organs to the rubber-like, contracted gritty masses met with at post-mortem examinations. He had no evidence that such a state could exist in a man who has not bored in rock containing a high percentage of free silica. Further, with reference to the observations on breathlessness and bronchitis among old coal miners, he would like to point out that all old miners were not breathless. It would be remembered that in the X-ray investigations carried out by the three teams under the supervision of Prof. Lyle Cummins, the men were all healthy to the best of their knowledge and did not complain of any disability. The average age of the men examined in the first group was 50 years, in the second group 42½ years, and in the third group 48 years. In each group there were men of 60 years and over; furthermore, only a proportion of these men showed abnormal X-ray negatives, and all of them probably in the coarse of their work drilled in stone, although none had done any actual hard heading work. An alternative explanation to dust as a cause of bronchitis was also mentioned by Dr. Haldane, namely, the heavy muscular exertion incidental to their work. There was also no evidence of which evidence of which he had heard that went to prove that coal dust alone materially damages a coal miner's lungs.

Committee Proposed.

The PRESIDENT said he would like to throw out a suggestion at that stage that the institute form a small committee of geologists, mineralogists and chemists, to endeavour to introduce some order in place of the confusion that existed in the terminology of certain sedimentary rocks which had been referred to by Prof. Cox. Such a committee could do a very useful piece of work.

Dr. A. HEARD (Geology Department, University College, Cardiff) said he had examined a large number of thin sections of lungs which were in an advanced stage of silicotic fibrosis. He decided to examine thin sections of the lungs of a cat and a kitten. These sections were prepared in an exactly similar manner, the same reagents being employed as in the preparation of sections of miners' fibrotic lungs. In every instance similar minute doubly-refracting crystals occurred. In some examples the minute crystals in a miner's lung were large enough to yield information of their approximate refractive index and optical sign. In such specimens the crystals were most certainly not quartz (free silica). In one instance micro-chemical tests revealed a relatively abnormally large crystal to he some compound of calcium. Moreover, these particles suggest an indio-morphic habit, which could not possibly occur in inhaled quartz dust. Quartz fragments had an irregular conchoidal fracture, which gave rise to characteristic dispersion of birefringence colours. Thus there appeared to be no direct mineralogical evidence that inhaled quartz fragments occurred in association with the fibrotic nodules. Apart from the statistics derived from cases of miners' silicosis in South Africa, there did not seem to be any conclusive evidence to support' the fact that the silicotic fibrosis of British miners was due solely to the inhaling of quartz dust. He was in complete agreement with Dr. R. Melville Hiley that "the combined silicates might not he the harmless and innocuous substances they are supposed to be." He had always wondered why such a relatively stable form of silica as quartz should be held responsible for silicosis, whilst the remainder of the rockforming silicates were ignored. Many of these silicates altered (geographically speaking), fairly readily, with in many cases an accompanying de-silicification, whilst the quartz in the same rock remained perfectly fresh. The possible effects of the silica thus liberated deserved some consideration from both the medical and legal authorities who were concerned with cases of silicosis.

Suggested Use for Anthracite Dust.

Mr. C. S. CHUBB (University College, Cardiff) thought the proportion of South Wales miners exposed to siliceous dust produced by drilling must be very small. The amount of heading work was small, and the amount traversing siliceous rocks only a fraction of that. The amount of ripping work was small compared with the weekly work of the collier, and the amount of ripping carried out in hard rock was minute. With such a hard rock it was preferable to cut bottom, and the amount of such ripping which was done by drilling was only a fraction of the whole. There were many other sources of dust in mines, but derived from rock which on the whole did not appear siliceous. The anomaly shown by the western area might be instructive. It bad been mentioned that that area differed from the other areas in that stone dust was not used there. Another very marked difference was the much greater quantity of drilling and shotfiring in that area. The drilling was, however, drilling in the coal. Would it benefit those in danger of silicosis if their working places could be dusted with anthracite dust as coal mines are now dusted with stone dust?

A Question of Terms.

Dr. H. CATTO (Newport) said he did not see why the condition of pulmonary tuberculosis in coal miners due to silica should not be called silicosis on the ground that it was not followed invariably by tuberculosis. With regard to Capt. Hay's remarks as to the necessity of knowing more about the size of the particles which were harmful, there was a consensus of opinion that the damage was done chiefly by particles of very small size. The larger particles visible macroscopically would very likely be caught in the larger bronchioles, and though they might produce local changes would not be likely to become phagocylised and to result in that diffuse fibrosis which was so very characteristic of this condition.

Dr. A. J. AMOR (Swansea) said after examining a considerable number of serial sections from cases of anthracosis and silicosts, he did not believe that mechanical injury by dust played ed an important part in the etiology of bronchitis, and the small amount of coal dust found in the bronchial lymphatics led him to believe that phagocytosis of dust by the bronchial epithelium rarely, if ever, occurred in man. Prof. Cummins' work on adsorption by coal dust was of great interest and prime importance. He himself had investigated this problem on anthracite coal dust but had not satisfied himself that adsorption with this type of coal did occur. As to the pathological effects of silica dust, he had noted the considerable precipitation of protein from tubercolons pleural exudate by alpha silicic acid — a point which, as far as he could discover, was not mentioned in the medical literature.

Dr. A. F. SLADDEN (Swansea) regretted that no figures had been forthcoming during the discussion from which it might be possible to gather the extent of pneumonoconiosis amongst the whole number of men working in the coal industry. large number of chemical analyses had shown beyond any question that silica, either free or combined, was in fact present in entirely abnormal amounts in all these "silicotic" lungs, and it was highly desirable from the pathological standpoint that methods of demonstrating the silica microscopically should be devised. He suggested that the technical difficulties of such demonstration were considerable and that this problem was well worth the attention of a research worker who could devote whole-time to its solution.

The Western Area.

Mr. THOMAS DIXON (Pontardawe) said the question of silicosis was arousing a deal of excitement in the western area of the coal field, and he hoped he was right in thinking that much of this excitement was unnecessary. Recently, he discovered an extraordinary fact which might prove useful to medical and other investigators. One grade of men worked on conveyers in groups of about 30 and their ability to produce coal seemed to be in inverse ratio to their ages ; the younger they were the less was their production and the older they were the greater their output.. And since the incidence of bronchitis and silicosis was greater in the later years of the miners' lives it seemed to follow that the more the bronchitis and the more the silicosis, the more effective the miner became as far as output was concerned! In order to get a correct interpretation of the facts they must be informed in more detail of the exact nature of the occupation of the men found to be suffering in the way described by the medical speakers.

The Legal Position.

The PRESIDENT stated that the position was very unsatisfactory from the scientific point of view and the legal position was still worse. First of all a regulation was made laying down that rocks were not to be included which contained less than 50 per cent, of free silica. There was no definition of "free silica," and one could only assume that it meant quartz; nor was there any method prescribed for determining the percentage of "free silica." Personally he had adopted Mellor's "rational analysis," which, after all, was only an approximate method. He had made a number of analyses of various rocks involved in the problem and there was, en the whole, a very fair correspondence, in the case of coarse-grained rocks, between the results of the approximate analysis of Mellor and of his own petrological examinations, but he felt very strongly that Prof. Cox was right about the necessity of a more accurate discrimination in the terminology of the different sedimentary rocks. To-day the 50 per cent., which had been laid down as a definite proportion had been replaced by specifications of the kind of rock. The rock must not be a quartz, quartzite, ganister, sandstone, "gritstone," or chert. Some of these terms were readily definable, but in the case of sandstones and grit stone he believed most geologists would find difficulty in stating exactly what was meant by the terms. He hardly thought that geologists spoke of "grit stone" at all; they spoke of grit and sandstone and their attention to the need for closer definition by the silicosis phase of the subject. It had hitherto been quite sufficient for the geologist to take the more or less popular descriptions of rocks and there had in the past been no need to consider the matter any further; but now the whole position was altered and it would be well if the geologists, mineralogists and chemists came together in order to specify the various rocks in greater detail. One might have sandstone presumably made up of what was originally sand, but what was sand? If it was siliceous what was the limit of size? What was the lowest limit of sand? Below sand came "silt"; what was the limit of silt? Some clays were very siliceous. Clays were, he thought, rocks that consisted largely of particles of colloidal size, and it seemed to be a matter of indifference what the material was as long as the particles were of colloidal size. It was obvious that these and similar questions should be thrashed out by a committee such as he had suggested.

There was a remarkable difference between the figures for the anthracite and Monmouthshire areas which required explanation. It might be that Prof. Cummins' theory was a correct one, for there was considerable evidence that the more bituminous coals had the power of adsorbing certain substances, and that that power of adsorption became greater as the rank of the coal decreased. If that was the explanation it fitted in very nicely with Prof. Cummins' theory.

The discussion, which had been most helpful, would be closed, subject to any written contributions that might be sent and to Prof. Cummins' reply to the points that had been raised.

Author's Reply.

Prof. CUMMINS, in replying to the points raised in the discussion, said he thought that there was much to be said in favour of a differentiation in nomenclature between various diseases produced by different kinds of dust. For the typical "coal miner's lung," as met with in South Wales, he preferred to adhere to the name suggested in his opening address, namely, silico-anthracosis. As to whether the fibrosis resulted only from free silica, or might be due also to silicates, he was unable to say, as the chemists had not yet devised an absolutely reliable method of differentiating the free front the combined silica, either in a sample of dust or in a sample of lung; but he did not think that the point was very important, either in relation to prevention or treatment. The importance of the name, "silico-anthracosis," was not negligible, however, as it gave point to the factors causing the condition, and so had a role in suggesting the necessary lines of prevention.

In reply to Capt. Hay, he welcomed the assurance that such a great advance had been and was being made in the extension of anti-dust precautions, and it was equally gratifying to learn that no less than 500 "Hay" dust traps, or modifications of Capt. Hay's beautiful apparatus in use throughout South Wales. He was also much interested to hear further details of the new anti-dust respirator which is being designed and tested at Porton, which seemed to offer a valuable advance towards a practical respirator for the mining industry.

He agreed with Capt. Hay that the state of our medical knowledge about silicosis left much to be desired. The great difficulty lay in the fact that' animal experiments afforded the only clear line of further investigation, and yet that animal experiments in dust inhalation are difficult, both in execution and in interpretation. Some recent attempts of his own had suggested to him that minute particles, such as dusts and bacteria, were more likely to enter the recesses of the lungs if suspended in a fine spray of water than if inhaled dry. That might, perhaps, on of using fine water sprays to throw down dust.

As to the size of particles to be regarded as dangerous, one thing seemed to him to point strongly to the conclusion that very minute silica particles were the most formidable. In the South African gold mines there had been a very great improvement in the dust content of the mine-air as gauged by the Kotze conimeter; yet silicosis still occurs. This suggested that the decrease in the relatively large dust particles visible to the low powers of the microscope used in reading the Kotze dust films did not correspond to an adequate diminution of the risk of silicosis, and that it was probable that far smaller particles, invisible with this instrument, and too small to be appreciably reduced by wet drilling, were keeping up the effect. It was to be hoped that the arrangements now being made by the Medical Research Council on the recommendations of their "Industrial Lung" Committee, will eventually throw much light on the medical side of the problems awaiting solution. Dr. Amor was mistaken in attributing to him the view that silica particles caused bronchitis by directly irritating the This might, perhaps, occur in the daily life of the miner in hard stone, but it could hardly account for the terminal bronchitis which arose years later. He agreed that the diagnosis of "bronchitis" was often made to fit a death otherwise hard to classify. He much preferred the term "dyspnoea" to the term "bronchitis" for the respiratory condition of old coal miners. He agreed with Dr. Amer that the term "bronchitis" was often applied to the last stages of a more fundamental disability. There was, however, no doubt that an element of bronchitis did exist in nearly all these cases, a bronchitis secondary to the peribronchial fibrosis produced by the inhalation of dust into the alveoli and its arrest in the peribronchial lymphatics.

He welcomed the suggestion made by Prof. Cox and supported by the president, that there should be a committee of chemists, geologists and, perhaps, physicists, to define more clearly the characters and properties of some of the rocks now relegated to an indeterminate position between the admittedly "hard" rocks on the one hand and the argillaceous rocks on the other.

The discussion was closed with cordial thanks to Prof. Cummins for his paper.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print