Museum Entrance Museum Entrance
Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
Colliery Guardian
Colliery Guardian - Main Index
Colliery Guardian - Subject Index
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Title Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Title
 
Masthead
February 5, 1932

A Century Of Fuel Economy.*

By Prof. William A. Bone, D.Sc., F.R.S. **

If the world's material progress can be assured by its consumption of coal and iron, how marvellous would be the record for the past century. A hundred years ago the world's production of iron was certainly less than 2 million tons per annum, in 1929 it had reached 97.25 million tons, or a fifty-fold increase. And, as regards coal, Sir Richard Redmayne, in his evidence before the 1925 Coal Commission, estimated the whole world's output in 1829 at 28.3 million tons — in 1929 it as just over 1,300 million tons, or a 45-fold increase during the century.

To put it in another way — in 1829 about 17 million people in Great Britain consumed some 600,000 tons of iron and steel, or about 80 lb. per head, per annum; in 1929, 45 millions of us, their descendants, consumed about 10 million tons, or about 500 lb. per head per annum, or a more than six-fold increase per capita. And as regards coal, the per capita increase has been five-fold.

The Manufacture of Iron and Steel.

My story opens with the epoch-making invention in 1828 of hot blast in iron smelting by James Beaumont Neilson, which signalised the dawn of fuel economy. Somehow Neilson had intuitively guessed that the expenditure of a given quantity of fuel (small coal) outside the furnace for the purpose of preheating the ingoing blast would save many times more fuel (coke) inside the furnace; and paradoxical though it seemed at first, trial soon proved it to be right. The first trials of the invention as applied to iron smelting were made at the Clyde ironworks, near Glasgow, early in 1929, and were immediately successful beyond the most sanguine anticipation. Lowthian Bell says that the actual direct saving of coke in the furnace itself per ton of iron smelted during the trials was 20 cwt., which had been achieved by imparting to the ingoing blast an amount of heat developed by the combustion of between 2 and 3 cwt of small coal outside the furnace, a result which he described as being in itself "sufficiently astounding."

This, however, was by no means all. For in Scotland Neilson's invention enabled the blackband ironstone, which had been discovered by David Mushet in 1802, to be smelted; moreover, Scottish iron masters were enabled to substitute raw coal for coke in their blastfurnaces. In Wales it enabled the use of anthracite as blastfurnace fuel, a practice which, on being transferred to America in 1840, founded the great Pennsylvania iron industry, which to-day has attained such colossal dimensions.

Although one or two sporadic attempts had been made to utilise these furnaces gases, it was not until 1845, when Bunsen and Playfair reported to the British Association at Cambridge the results of their analyses of the gases at various levels in a coal-fired blastfurnace at Alfreton in Derbyshire, that the enormity of the waste was fully realised. Bunsen and Playfair pointed out that such furnaces "are peculiarly adopted for the economy in gaseous fuels, which may be conducted from the furnace and applied without in any way interfering with its operation." The response of the industry was immediate, for in the same year J. P. Budd, of Ystalyfera, patented a stove for heating the blast by means of the furnace gases, and shortly afterwards he used them for firing boilers also. In 1850 G. Parry introduced at Ebbw Vale his well-known "cup and cone" device for closing the throat of the blast furnace so that its gases might be led off and utilised. Finally during the early sixties (1860-65) E. A. Cowper and Thomas Whitwell, two Cleveland engineers, independently invented their hot-blast stoves fired by furnace gases on regenerative principles, which made possible much higher blast temperatures than had oven been attained in the old coal-fired stoves.

This soon led to a rapid increase in blastfurnace dimensions, which was the next step in the progress of fuel economy. Two monster furnaces, each 103 ft. high and 33,000 cu. ft. capacity, were erected at Ferryhill in the county of Durham in 1868. Also, in that year, Charles Cochrane, of Middlesbrough, made his famous prediction that "enough heat might be conveyed into the furnace with the blast to enable a ton of iron to be produced from Cleveland stone with 13 cwt. of coke." But it was not fulfilled by the performance of the Ferryhill giants, and it soon became evident that the increase in furnace dimensions had overshot the mark.

The controversy which ensued led Lowthian Bell to carry out in his laboratories at the Clarence works his fundamental investigation of the laws governing the complex chemical interactions in the blastfurnace, the results of which, on being published in his classical "Chemical Phenomena of Iron Smelting in 1872," completely altered the problem. For he proved beyond dispute that the reduction of the ore by the furnace gases is governed by the law of "mass-action" which makes it impossible to utilise, within the furnace itself, more than a certain fraction — which Bell considered as about 53 per cent. of the total available energy of the coke charged into it. He then proceeded on the assumption that it would not be practicable to pre-heat the blast to more than 1,000 deg. Cent. (1,832 deg. Fahr.), a point which in fact has never been exceeded, if indeed reached — to define what he regarded as the practicable limits of fuel economy in a Cleveland furnace. In regard to Cleveland practice, he considered the limiting furnace dimensions to be a height of 80 ft. combined with a capacity of 16,000 cu. ft., and that "taking the ordinary run of Durham coal and Cleveland ironstone . . . it is useless to hope to smelt a ton of grey iron . . with notably under 20½ cwt. of coke" no matter how high the blast temperature. It should, therefore, be remembered that Bell's prediction referred to the smelting of calcined Cleveland ores with Durham coke, for, although it has been fulfilled by all subsequent experience with such ores, it by no means applies universally, and certainly not to richer ores, especially under modern conditions of "hard driving," which Bell could not possibly have foreseen 60 years ago.

Moreover, since Bell's day, it has been found that the equilibrium ratio CO/CO2 in the furnace gases depends not merely on the temperature but also upon the degree of ore reduction, which comprises three stages. The first of these, which is completed in the upper regions of the furnace, is irreversible and, according to recent determinations in my laboratories at the Imperial College — which accord well with those previously made by Matsubara in 1921 — it would appear as though the practicable limit of fuel economy in any given circumstance must largely, if not mainly, depend upon such factors as the texture and reducibility of the ore, the total burden of the furnace per unit of iron produced, and the rate of driving. Probably the chief reason for the beneficial operation of hot blast is that it raises the temperature and consequently speeds up the reducing action of the gases at all levels throughout the furnace.

In 1904 James Gayley proved that further fuel economies are attainable by drying the blast. The question whether or not it would pay to dry the blast in given circumstances depends upon whether the cost of the drying operation exceeds or not that of the coke which would be saved thereby. At one time furnaces were successfully operated with dry blast in both this country and America, but I am informed that none are so now.

In smelting their native ores, Cleveland ironmasters, although they have not reduced their coke consumption below the limits which Bell had assigned as the lowest practicable, have increased their weekly output about threefold and are utilising these furnace gases much more efficiently in ways which would fully gratify his genius for economy. But his astonishment would be excited by modern achievements in smelting haematites by the intensive methods which originated in America, where enormous reserves of rich or easily reducible ores are favourable to hard driving and colossal outputs, which in some cases have now reached the marvellous figure of 1,000 tons per diem. It should, however, be pointed out that such astounding records are only possible in smelting low-silica iron for subsequent conversion into steel, and can hardly be expected in smelting typical foundry irons.

As the result of a century's effort a blastfurnace has now produced as much iron in an hour as one did in a week in 1829, and at about a fifth the cost in fuel. Besides which, it has required the development of mechanical devices whereby in every minute of the week some 2.135 tons of material are hoisted up 90 ft. and automatically charged into the furnace, a ton of iron and slag is removed at the bottom, about 70,000 cu. ft. of air are preheated and pumped through the tuyeres, and some 90,000 en. ft. of gas conducted away from the top and utilised in adjacent appliances. And the germ of all this lay in Neilson's invention, which after a century's development has resulted in a direct fuel saving on the whole world's present output of iron which cannot he computed at less than about 100 million tons of coke per annum.

With regard to recent blastfurnace coke consumptions in this country, investigations made by the British Association Fuel Economy Committee showed that in 1916-17 Bell's limit of 20.5 cwt. of Durham coke for smelting calcined Cleveland ore had not been reached; indeed, owing to some deterioration both in the ore and in the quality (ash content) of Durham coke since Bell's time, the consumption has tended to increase in recent years, and 23.5 cwt. in 1916-17 would be equivalent to no more than about 22 cwt. fifty years ago. The high coke consumption in Lincolnshire furnaces is largely due to the low iron content and refractoriness of the ore smelted.

The following more recent figures for the whole Kingdom (including Scottish furnaces using raw coal instead of coke) kindly supplied to me by the National Federation of Iron and Steel Manufacturers, have shown a decided improvement in fuel economy since the war, the total coal equivalent per ton of pig iron having now been reduced to 37.76 cwt. as the basis of a coke/coal ratio = 0.66

Leaving the ore smelting, let us now consider what science has accomplished in saving fuel during the later manufacturing stages. A century ago, save for relatively small quantities made by the crucible process for weapons, tools and the like, there was next to no steel, but the crude product of the blastfurnace was laboriously converted into wrought iron in puddling furnaces at a further expenditure of some 20 to 30 cwt. per ton of small coal and for nearly 40 years afterwards wrought iron continued to be the material used in railway and ship building.

It was the genius of Henry Bessemer that conceived the idea of the foreign elements in molten pig iron — which were eliminated in the puddling furnace — being sufficiently combustible to enable their elimination being effected in a few minutes without human labour by a simple process of air blowing, the heat generated thereby more than sufficing to keep the bath molten throughout the process. While Bessemer himself (with the aid of Mushet and manganese) solved the problem for non-phosphoric haematite pig iron by means of his "acid"-lined converter, it remained for George Snelus to propose in 1872, and Thomas and Gilchrist to achieve in 1880 the solution of the problem as regards phosphoric pig iron, by means of their basic-lined converter." Taken altogether, however, the invention of the pneumatic process, in each of its two forms, most be ranked among the world's greatest metallurgical fuel-economy achievements. For, in 1929 there were produced about 30 million tons of pneumatic steel, a third of it in "acid"-lined and the remainder in "basic"-lined converters. Incidentally also, it was the solution of the basic pneumatic problem by Thomas and Gilchrist in 1872 that alone made it possible f or Germany, Luxemburg and France to exploit commercially the enormous reserves of phosphoric "minette iron ores of Lorraine and Luxemburg, and to produce therefrom cheap steel in severe competition with our own industry which has now almost abandoned pneumatic methods. And the fact that in the year 1929 our chief Continental rivals (France, Germany, Belgium and Luxemburg) produced upwards of 20 million tons of such cheap steel, practically all of it in "basic" converters, whereas we produced 527,700 tons only, makes one wonder whether it would not pay us to revert more to pneumatic methods, the quality of whose products, though inferior to open-hearth steel, nevertheless suffices for many purposes.

While the pneumatic process for converting pig iron into steel was being developed, the brothers William and Frederick Siemens were successfully applying their gas-fired open-hearth regenerative furnace to the purpose. The open-hearth steel process began its successful career about the year 1867-8 and after further developments it has become the world's chief process for the production of mild steel, and especially of the higher qualities thereof. Openhearth furnaces of anything up to 250 tens capacity, capable of producing 1,000 tons each of steel per week, have been operated. The fuel expenditure in modern practice naturally depends upon the proportion of cold to molten metal charged into the furnace, but in modern American practice, using "mixed processes" in which the charge is composed of about 50/50 molten pig and scrap, coal consumption as low as 4 cwt. per ton of steel is not uncommon. Taking, however, 5 to 6 cwt of coal gasified in the producer per ton of steel as a fair average f or modern plants using charges mainly composed of molten metal, we arrive at the conclusion that the open-hearth steel process has now reduced the fuel consumption in refining pig iron to about a fourth what it used to be in the old puddling process which it displaced.

Finally, we come to what nowadays may be regarded as the practicable ideal of fuel economy in a modern iron and steel works producing ordinary steel sections. This baa been made possible as the cumulative result of several great technical developments, all of which have been made during the past 50 years, as, for example

(i) in the manufacture of metallurgical coke in "regenerative" chamber ovens with by-product recovery;

(ii) in the generation of power in internal combustion engines from cleaned blastfurnace gas;

(iii) in the cleaning of blastfurnace gas, and the improved combustion efficiency of the cleaned gas

(iv) in the generation of electric power therefrom, and the electrical driving of rolling mills and other machinery, and

(v) in the substitution of electrically driven turbo-blowers for the old steam driven reciprocating blowing engines at the blastfurnace.

The rapid development of by-product coking ovens which, beginning in the 'nineties, culminated during the early years of this century in the regenerative oven, made available large surpluses of rich gas from the manufacture of metallurgical coke. In 1916, through my association with the enterprise at Skinningrove, I was able to publish a diagram showing the concentration and disposition of plant requisite for the production of a ton of finished steel sections from Cleveland ironstone with the expenditure of no more than 16 tons (32 cwt.) of Durham coal charged into the coke ovens. It should, however, be realised that the achievement of such an ideal would mean not only the proper selection, concentration and co-ordination of all the operative units on one site, but also scientific management and control throughout the whole heating system by properly trained fuel technologists, so that every available heat unit in the plant shall be tracked down and effectively utilised to the best advantage. For, even after all that has been indicated is accomplished, there would still remain such problems as the utilisation of (i) the heat carried off in the molten slag — which in a Cleveland furnace is equivalent to that in about 2.62 cwt. of coke per ton of iron, or about 11.65 per cent, of the heat of combustion of the carbon charged (as coke) into the furnace — and (ii) the sensible heat now carried off in the hot products of combustion from the hot blast stoves, open-hearth furnaces, gas engines and the like, which in the aggregate would be equivalent to that in about another 1.5 cwt. of coke.

Doubtless it will be asked how nearly has our "practicable ideal" of 1.75 tons of coal per ton of finished steel sections been achieved by the end of the century now under review? This is a question not so easily answered, since the war upset things and post-war circumstances, in this country at any rate, have been unfavourable. So far as the Skinningrove works were concerned, although the war prevented certain changes and substitutions in plants being made that were necessary for the attainment of the ideal, the total of coal consumed per ton of ingots from the smelting of the ore up to finished steel sections has been brought down to as low as 41.65 cwt. With regard to other works, in a paper by Bassal and Rocaut, published in 1928, figures were given for a basic Bessemer plant at the Trinec works (Czechoslovakia) showing a total coal consumption per ton of finished and semi-finished steel of the order of 26.4 cwt. which, it another 6 cwt. were added in respect of what would have been required for conversion of the pig metal into steel in an open-hearth furnace, would be equivalent to not more than about 32.4 cwt. of coal for a corresponding open-hearth steel plant.

Owing to the difficult conditions prevailing in this country since the great coal strike of 1926, our iron and steel works have been at a great disadvantage, also the much larger proportions of "scrap" used nowadays than formerly in the open-hearth furnace charges has upset the works fuel balances, But I am reliably informed that in the year 1929 the best practice in the country was that at a works on the north-east coast, where the total coal consumption was of the order of 500,000 tons for an output of nearly 240,000 of finished steel — or just under 42 cwt. per ton of steel, and that if a complete balance between pig icon and steel existed, there are plants now operating upon British ores capable of producing a ton of finished steel therefrom with a total consumption of less than 2 tons of coal.

The Manufacture Of Gas and Coke.

Although the manufacture of coke for metallurgical coke is the oldest coal carbonising industry, until the middle of last century its methods remained so primitive that it is in the younger gas industry, born of the experiments of William Murdoch at Redruth. in 1792, and established in the metropolis in 1813, that we shall find the first glimmers of science in the process.

According to figures given by Accum in 1819, 107 chaldrons (= 144½ tons) of coal gave 1,070,000 on. ft. (= 7,425 cu. ft. per ton) of gas, which sold at 15s. per thousand, the full expenditure being 26¾ chaldrons of small coal, or practically 25 per cent, of the coal carbonised. The conditions were those of a fairly low-temperature carbonisation, and as the coke was very free burning and sold at 27s. a chaldron, it was much used for domestic purposes throughout the metropolis.

Fireclay retorts were apparently first used in Scotland about the year 1825, and Neilson introduced them at the Glasgow works about that time, but they did not rapidly displace iron retorts, and it was not until about 1860 that their use became general, in which year also, at the suggestion of Mr. Croll, the practice of drawing red-hot coke straight from the retort for firing the setting came in as a heat economy measure. The substitution of fireclay for iron retorts allowed of the carbonising temperature being raised, probably up to about 850 deg. Cent., with consequent increase in the make of gas, hut at some additional cost in fuel, which now amounted to some 30 per cent, of the total coke made.

The period 1875-80 marked the introduction of hot gas firing from "generators" built into the setting in place of the old direct fired furnace, combined with heat recuperators or regenerators for the preheating of the air supply to the setting, and by 1890 the firing of retort settings by such means bad become general in all the larger works. This meant still higher carbonising temperatures, increased makes of gas, coupled with lower fuel consumptions, which, by 1884, in London works bad fallen to 22 per cent, of the total coke made.

Meanwhile the invention of the atmospheric burner, since universally called after him, by R. W. Bunsen, at Heidelberg, in 1855, and the pioneering work in this country of Thomas Fletcher, opened up a vast new field for gas, which has since become its principal use. Also, the invention of the incandescent mantle (1890-93) by Auer von Weisbach, enabled gas for many years afterwards successfully to maintain its position in regard to domestic lighting, from which, however, it has since been largely ousted by electricity, although for street lighting it still remains supreme. Also the invention, some 20 years ago, of methods realising the phenomenon of incandescent surface combustion extended the use of coal gas f or heating purposes.

In 1885 inclined retort settings were introduced on the Continent, mainly from the point of view of labour saving, and a considerable number of them were installed in Great Britain from about 1890 until the War, but since that time they have been superseded by vertical. The beginning of the present century witnessed the successful development in Germany of vertical retort settings of the intermittent type in 1902, and in this country of the continuous type in 1903.

For several years prior to the war a few of the gas undertakings had commenced mixing a certain proportion of "water gas" (sometimes "carburetted") with the straight coal gas before supplying it to consumers. The cities of Birmingham, Sheffield and Glasgow led the way in supplying coal gas for industrial purposes. During the war "steaming" the incandescent coke charge in vertical retorts was introduced as a means of increasing the total yield of gas, and after the new Gas Regulation Act in 1920, the practice was widely extended, with consequent (i) increased thermal efficiency and B.th.u. in the gas yield per ton, but (ii) gas of lower volumetric calorific values, e.g., mostly 450 to 500 B.th.u. per en. ft., and (iii) some detriment to the coke.

In 1916 the use of silica as a refractory material for both retorts and combustion chambers began, and has since become widely extended. Another important step towards greater thermal efficiency has been the increasing use of waste heat boilers, whereby part of the sensible heat of the burnt gases from the combustion chambers and regeneration of the retort settings is utilised for steam raising.

Although it is difficult to give really comparative data for carbonising processes over so long a century, yet I think the past century's progress is fairly epitomised in the following table, which has been compiled partly from Frederick Accum's data and partly from those kindly furnished me by Mr. Thomas Hardie and others; it represents average daily works results, and not those of special efficiency trials

During the year 1930, the authorised gas undertakings of Great Britain carbonised 17.67 million tons of coal with an average make of 14,451 on. ft. of gas per ton, or a total of 255,000 million cu. ft., a considerable proportion of which was used for industrial purposes.

(To be continued.)


* Abstract of Melchett lecture, delivered before the Institute of Fuel on the occasion of the presentation of the Melchett medal, February 1, 1932.

** Chief professor and head of the Department of Chemical Technology at the Imperial College of Science and Technology, London.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print