Museum Entrance Museum Entrance
Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
Colliery Guardian
Colliery Guardian - Main Index
Colliery Guardian - Subject Index
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Title Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Title
 
Masthead
February 5, 1932

Colliery Damage Claims.*

By H. A. Booth.

Liability for Damage.

The owner of the surface of land is presumed in law to be entitled to support from the subjacent strata. The natural right of support may have been lost by severance or in some other way, but without direct evidence to the contrary it is assumed that the surface owner of freehold land has a right to compensation in the event of damage being caused to his property by mining operations.

The legal position seems far from clear. In parts of County Durham colliery companies have ceased paying damages on land that was formerly unenclosed common, relying for support on the Consett-Co-operative Society's case (the Consett Industrial and Provident Society, Ltd., v. the Consett Iron Co., Ltd., 1921). It was unfortunate that this case did not go to the House of Lords. The Court of Appeal decided in the colliery company's favour, but prior to the hearing by the Lords the company bought the farm in question.

It has been asserted that on a change of tenancy the new tenant is only entitled to crop damages in respect of new damage that occurs subsequent to his entry, and one colliery company to my knowledge has up to the present successfully disputed tenants' claims on these grounds. No case has, however, been heard on the subject.

The Assessment of Claims.

On receipt of a complaint, if it refers to an area where damages have not previously been paid, the responsible colliery representative examines his working plans to ascertain if there are workings which may have caused the damage.

Questions frequently arise as to whether certain workings have or have not caused alleged damage. Liability may be disputed on the ground of the length of time that has elapsed since the coal was worked, or because when it was worked it was only to pillars and not goafed, or because of the horizontal distance between the workings and the alleged damage, or possibly on other grounds.

It is sometimes said by mining engineers that settlement will have ceased in five years, but it obviously depends on the depth of the seam; further, whether 2 ft. 6 in. of coal have been removed; whether there is hard rock between the coal seams and the surface. If the coal is left in pillars it will naturally take very much longer to settle than if it has been goafed. No settlement is possible unless the timbers are allowed to rot and falls take place, and even then, when pillars are left, the surface is not likely to be seriously affected except where the coal seams are near the surface. When the seams are deep one can never tell when subsidence will first be noticed at the surface

It is usually held that goaf workings may affect the surface to a maximum horizontal distance equal to one-third the depth of the seam. It must be remembered, however, that where recent workings are in the vicinity of old workings, movement may he started which may result in damage to land a considerable distance away. This is always a question of some difficulty. The extent of damage is affected by the class of overlying strata and the dip of the seam.

Another contentious matter that arises now and then is the drawing off by recent workings, of water accumulated in old workings. Sonic authorities state that such water cannot support the surface and therefore drawing it off cannot cause subsidence. Others assert that there is bound to be loss of support and consequent settlement.

Another disputed question is whether a colliery is responsible for settlement in a limestone area where there is pumping, resulting in caverns being formed in the limestone which cave in periodically, particularly where coal is goafed underneath these cavities.

Crops.

This is the type of claim which is being dealt with regularly. Where there is a shortage of crop caused by colliery workings, the colliery has to make good the deficiency.

Damage to crops is usually easily visible, but naturally it is recognised more readily by the experienced eye. Some of our expert valuers for an adequate fee would no doubt find distinct traces of damage in the heart of the Cheviots. The effect is seen in the poorer yield in certain places in the field as compared with other parts of the same field having a similar soil which has received the same treatment. The loss is arrived at by estimating the deficiency per acre on the damaged portion and applying it to the number of acres damaged.

There are, of course, numerous difficulties in practice. Although coal may have been worked, all or part of the damage may be due to other causes. Then one has to contend with the deliberate swindler. Seed may be missed or only sparsely sown on damaged patches of land. Cultivations may similarly be scamped in these places. Fertilisers such as sulphate of ammonia may be unevenly distributed to emphasise the difference between undamaged and damaged area. Owing to the wet state of the soil it may have been impossible to get on to it to carry out cultivations, and the presence of weeds may be the result of wetness and not the cause of the poor crop. Allowance must also be made for difficulty in reaping.

In the case of the potato crop, there is also the debatable problem of how far colliery damage may be responsible for rot and disease setting in. This year I have known of two cases where claims of 50 tons were agreed in a single field. The crop deficiency is agreed before it is reaped, hay crops being usually inspected about the end of June, corn in August, root crops in September and onwards. Pasture land is generally settled with the roots when the damage is most visible. The produce prices are, however, not fixed until the autumn, usually the first week in November. This is not the market price, but the market price less the estimated cost of harvesting and marketing.

Grass land sometimes presents a little trouble, because there is no natural crop to see.

Draining is sometimes carried out by the colliery company to avoid or reduce damage claims. It frequently pays to do this where standing water regularly damages crops. Sometimes a damage "rent" is paid on the understanding that no crop is sown or, if it is sown, that there will be no liability on the colliery. Again, to avoid large claims for corn or potatoes, the colliery may pay for the cost of laying an amble field down to grass and then pay only a smaller sum for any damage the grass may sustain.

Woodland is occasionally affected by colliery workings. I have not yet heard of a case of a claim for deficiency in crop due to excess or loss of water, although woodlands are adversely affected by both these factors. But I have recovered from the colliery the cost of ditching in wet places, and no doubt a claim would lie for trees pulled over as a result of pitfalls.

Buildings.

Whilst damages to buildings caused by colliery workings are naturally a subject for compensation, the usual practice is for the colliery to repair the damage if this is possible. But it is obvious that where walls have dropped, where doorways and windows have become distorted, in fact, wherever the building has moved bodily, there can be no question of repair. In these cases, therefore, the colliery is faced with rebuilding, or paying compensation on this basis. The colliery is in the unenviable position of being called upon to make good damage to the same property any number of times. When both parties are reasonable, patchwork repairs are usually agreed to until the coal has been wrought and settlement has ceased. There is then a possibility that the works that are carried out will carry some lasting benefit.

In colliery districts cracks in the walls of cottages are frequently simply grouted and pointed up, but it should be appreciated that this cannot be said to restore the property to its original condition. The only way properly to repair a crack is to remove the adjacent brick or stone work and build in afresh so that the work is bonded together. Alternatively, the cracks can be pointed and a claim made for permanent deterioration.

Loss of Water.

This is of frequent occurrence where coal is being worked. Both ponds and water courses may disappear, and existing pipe lines may be broken. Collieries may be put to considerable expense in conveying water to reinstate the supply, depending naturally on the distance from the nearest source of supply. They have then to maintain the line as far as damage by pitfalls is concerned, and where land is badly damaged this may mean almost continuous work on the pipes. Pipes seem to be very easily fractured in these circumstances, and failing immediate repair, the colliery responsible has to meet the cost of the water which runs to waste.

Smoke Damages, etc.

Another claim which falls upon collieries from time to time is that for smoke damage by smoke and fumes, and this as a rule is caused by burning pit heaps. The damage to crops is usually serious, the fumes shrivelling up vegetation close at hand and stunting the growth of crops more remote from the fire. Clover and turnip crops are particularly affected. One claim I recently settled in respect of damage caused by fumes in one field alone amounted to £80 in twelve months. it is said that an indirect loss is sometimes suffered owing to beasts being affected by consuming tainted hay. Since collieries have gone in more for coal screening plants claims have arisen owing to damages caused by flying coal dust.

Damage is also caused to land adjoining spoil heaps by foul drainage out of the heaps running over the surface. The polluted water kills all vegetable growth, and if the soil is a heavy clay with inefficient drains the damage may be extensive.

In all the above cases compensation is, of course, based upon the loss of crops suffered by the occupier.

Other losses include the loss by animals falling into pitfalls. Cases of cattle being injured in cracks and potholes, and of horses going down into an unsuspected pitfall, are not uncommon.

Permanent Damage Settlements.

A permanent settlement in respect of colliery damage is one made to meet all liabilities for damage caused up to the date of the settlement. Such a settlement is made on the termination of a lease, when an area of land has been worked out, or at other times by arrangement. At the present time, when the coal trade is at a low ebb, a permanent settlement is delayed as long as possible to avoid the lump sum payment involved. The measure of the settlement is the depreciated value of the land and buildings affected. As far as buildings are concerned, the compensation is represented by the cost of reinstatement, having due regard to natural decay. Compensation in respect of the land is arrived at by estimating the reduction in letting value and capitalising this figure. Theoretically this should be the same as the cost of reinstatement, but in actual fact the cost of levelling, draining, and otherwise returning the land to its original condition would in some cases be very much more than the land would ever be worth. The year's purchase varies from 15 to 20. In the case of badly potholed land the compensation may amount to nearly the fee simple value. Any loss of water would have to be taken into account in arriving at the settlement.

Once a permanent settlement has been made only claims for new damage will be entertained and, as may be expected, there can be considerable argument as to the measure of any new damage. Even when levels have definitely altered, the extent to which the surface has dropped is no guide to the compensation payable; the loss is, of course, the damage sustained.

General.

It will be seen from the foregoing that the settlement of damages is a very expensive item for collieries. As far as crops are concerned the extent of the damage depends to a great extent upon the season. In a dry season damages are not so noticeable, but in a wet year such as this the effects are aggravated. In the latter case it is very difficult to say how far the season alone is responsible for the losses. It is, of course, owing to their heavy responsibilities in this respect that so many colliery companies during recent years have bought up farms under which they are working. In most cases it will be to their advantage to pay an enhanced price for a farm rather than have to meet annual crop damage claims, sometimes exceeding the rent paid by an occupier.

The valuer practising in a colliery district can never allow this subject to stray far from his mind, for nearly all his valuations are affected in some way by considerations of colliery damage — its extent, the colliery responsible, whether admitted and paid for, whether there has been any permanent settlement, and so on. Unfortunately, the legal position is so uncertain that no exact estimate of its effect upon value can be made. It is probable that a number of companies are getting away with a disclaimer of liability simply owing to the lack of money to oppose them. On the other hand, I am perfectly certain that others are paying for damage which is not colliery damage at all, owing to having admitted liability in the past.

Before concluding, there is one other aspect of damages to which I might refer and that is the question of prevention. In the brine pumping areas of Cheshire, serious damage has been suffered by subsidence, and owing to the difficulty of allocating responsibilities for the damage, compensation is met out of a brine compensation fund to which the brine owners contribute. But in that district they have gone much further. In order to prevent, or at any rate to reduce, claims, all new houses have to he constructed within an oak or iron girder framework. Provision is made that in the event of any settlement the houses can be restored to their proper level by means of jacks. The cost of this comes out of the brine compensation fund. Practically nothing of this kind is done in the mining areas of Northumberland and Durham. It is only exceptionally that buildings are built upon a concrete raft. It is principally, no doubt, a matter of a small semi-villa on a concrete foundation capable of being levelled would add something like £40 to the cost. If there were 12 houses to the acre this would mean an additional cost of, say, £500 for every acre of land so built upon.

An acre of coal 12 in. thick represents approximately 1,500 tons, so that if there were two seams of coal each 3 ft. in thickness this would mean about 9,000 tons of coal to the acre; about 30 per cent, of this can be worked without much fear of damage. In the case of building land the remaining 70 per cent. would normally be sterilised owing to fear of damage. But, before it would be worth while initiating any preventive measures such as I have indicated this coal would have to be worth more than 2s. per ton. At the present time, of course, it is not worth anything hike this to the royalty owner and coal owner combined. Should the coal trade ever enjoy unexpected prosperity it is possible some such measures may enable a landowner to have both a royalty from coal and a building price for his surface land.


* From a paper read before the Northumberland and Durham branch of the Chartered Surveyors' Institution, Newcastle-upon-Tyne, November 18, 1931.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print