Museum Entrance Museum Entrance
Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
Colliery Guardian
Colliery Guardian - Main Index
Colliery Guardian - Subject Index
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Title Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Title
 
Masthead
January 8, 1932

Dust Prevention In The Coal Industry.

Prof. S. LYLE CUMMINS, M.D., of the Welsh National School of Medicine, Cardiff, read his paper on "The Need for Dust Prevention Measures in the Coal Industry,"* at the December meeting of the South Wales Institute of Engineers at Cardiff, when the President (Mr. CLARENCE A. SEYLER, B.Sc., F.I.C., Swansea) occupied the chair.

The PRESIDENT said the paper was very opportune. It had been arranged that the discussion be opened by the medical men, who would be followed by the geologists, chemists and engineers. At a later stage he would put forward, as a chemist, an interesting point which. confirmed Prof. Lyle Cummins' experimental result as to the adsorption of toxins by coal.

Dr. Haldane's Warning.

Dr. J. S. HALDANE (Oxford) said the opinions he had already expressed were largely in agreement with those brought forward by Prof. Lyle Cummins. The main new point that had emerged was that in a quite appreciable proportion of colliers who had never worked in stone, nor, in some cases, ever passed along stone-dusted roads, X-ray appearances indicative of scattered fibrosis, and similar to the appearances in undoubted silicosis, could be found after long service in an appreciable proportion of apparently healthy colliers, among whom no tendency to tubercular infection could be discovered. But when they came to the interpretation of the facts there was a divergence of opinion. The mortality among colliers from both phthisis and bronchitis, as well as from almost every other cause, had fallen steadily during the last 70 years, but so had the corresponding death-rates among the general population, though not in the same ratio, till after about 1900. In the last decennial returns published there was still, however, a well marked excess of deaths from bronchitis among colliers above about 55. He could not find, however, any justification in the official statistics for Dr. Tatham's statement that bronchitis had increased since about 1890. There had been a steady decrease all the time. In his paper on the health of old colliers he concluded that the essential cause of the unusual mortality from bronchitis among old colliers was the fact that their hard muscular work put an excessive strain on their lungs, leading to over-stretching or emphysema, and consequent shortness of breath, and liability to dangerous bronchitis. The strain during muscular work was immensely increased when, as used to be commonly the case in coal mines, there was as much as two or three per cent. of carbon dioxide in the air; and he attributed the decrease in the bronchitis death rate mainly to the much better ventilation. The statistics for different mining districts showed, however, that there were marked differences among them in the death rates from bronchitis and other causes. In the anthracite districts of South Wales, for instance, the death rates were unusually high; and this suggested that there might be something specially irritating in anthracite dust. The recent X-ray investigations described by Prof. Lyle Cummins seemed to confirm this, and also showed that it was not uncommon to find among elderly colliers of all sorts scattered fibrosis due to dust. He would like to know what the death rate from bronchitis was amongst the rest of the population in the anthracite area. Almost the only point in which he did not agree with Prof. Lyle Cummins was in extending the term silicosis to cover any form of fibrosis due to the inhalation of dust. This seemed inadvisable since there was no evidence that various forms of actual fibrosis were in fact due to inhalation of free silica and not to other forms of dust, such as coal dust or shale dust, which produced no tendency towards tubercular phthisis. It seemed preferable to distinguish these latter forms as "pneumoconiosis," since the word "silicosis" had come to have a very sinister significance.

Prof. Cummins bad put forward a very interesting theory as to the adsorption of tuberculin by coal dust. There was no doubt that coal dust did adsorb a number of substances in an extraordinary way. It was now well known that it adsorbed methane because practically the whole of the methane that came out of the coal was adsorbed in a liquid form as well as a still larger quantity of carbon dioxide in the exceptional cases, unknown in this country, where carbon dioxide was present under pressure in coal strata.

He wished to take this opportunity of entering an emphatic protest against the idea that the danger of miners' phthisis or silicosis in the sense in which he himself applied the term was necessarily proportional to the amount of free silica breathed. The shale dust which had been breathed by coal miners in large amount for generations contained often about 30 per cent, of free silica, though coal miners had a remarkably low death rate from phthisis. Coal miners must breathe far more free silica than the Transvaal gold miners now did. When the free silica was mixed with the other constituent of shale schists, etc., it produced no phthisis. In the Mysore gold mines, although the gold occurred in quartz reefs, just as in the Transvaal, the dust was mixed with that from schist about and below the quartz and produced no harm, although a great deal was breathed owing to the dry conditions. Analysis of the mixed dust shows about 25 per cent, of free silica according to analysis made by Mr. Shaw, of the Birmingham Mining Research Laboratory. In the dust from the Morrho Velho mine, the deepest in the world, the air was extremely dry and a great deal of dust was breathed In this dust Mr. Shaw found about 17 per cent, of free silica. Various hard stones which were quarried and crushed or dressed for roadmaking purposes in England and Scotland seemed also to cause no miners' phthisis owing to the admixture of free silica with other substances.

Although the mortality statistics for coal miners as a whole showed no indication of the existence among them of miners' phthisis, we now knew, thanks to investigations in recent years that undoubted cases did occur. It was in the small Somerset coal field that his own attention was drawn to these cases through a report by Mr. Swift, the miners' agent.. They were quite typical cases, similar in every way to those which he had been familiar with in Cornwall and particularly among men returning from the Rand mines. They occurred among men working in stone drifts in a local sandstone known as "Greys." About the same time a number of similar cases were reported in South Wales by Dr. Tattersall and others. The conditions in which the men had been working with machine drills seemed to have been quite as dangerous as during the worst conditions in the Rand mines. The absence of precautions was a breach of the Coal Mines Act of 1911, but no one seemed to have realised the dangerous consequences and he thought the inspectors of mines must take a certain share in the blame. In cases of work in sandstone or other highly siliceous rock the utmost precaution should be strictly enforced. The most effective precaution during drilling was the dust trap first introduced by Capt. Hay. In addition the headings should be well ventilated and the dust produced by blasting thoroughly removed from the air before the men returned. The rock broken should also be wetted to prevent dust being raised in shifting it. For less harmful dust produced locally by machine drills or other mining machinery, dust masks would be sufficient. He thought that the new facts brought forward by Prof. Cummins showed distinctly that even the less harmful kind of dust could produce serious pneumoconiosis and consequent disablement. New mining machinery, including conveyers, should be carefully considered from this point of view.

Dr. Sladden's Experience.

Dr. A. F. SLADDEN (Beck Laboratory, Swansea) said the apparent increase in the number of cases of "silicosis" recently was to be ascribed to the new conditions existing since the enforcement of new Home Office Regulations in 1929. This had led to post-mortem examinations on coal miners who previously would not have been examined. In Dr. Sladden's own experience, during the four years 1925-28, the bodies of 20 coal miners were examined. One had advanced "silicosis" and seven others slighter degrees of the condition. From 1929 onwards 63 examinations were made, 27 showing definite and serious degrees of "silicosis" and 16 others slighter degrees. The above examinations include a number of deaths from accident occurring during work; it was not uncommon to find a moderate degree of "silicosis" in such cases, but of an extent compatible with a full day's work. Tuberculosis had not been a common finding in these cases, and when found was usually in the younger men. If technically present in other cases it could not be demonstrated by ordinary microscopic methods, and certainly appeared to play no part of importance in leading to death. The existence of a fibrosis of lungs, independent of tuberculosis and sufficiently extensive to he the prime cause of death, in the coal miner appeared to be beyond question. That it was due to the effects of dust primarily seemed also to be unquestionable, and the experience in South Wales, and analyses made, point very strongly to silica as the essential cause. None of the bad cases were free of silica in large amounts; some had much coal dust, but not all.

Prof. Haldane preferred the more general term "pneumoconiosis" to be applied to these cases; there was no serious objection to this terminology pending the general acceptance of silica as the dust at fault. The figures quoted from the returns of the Registrar-General should be viewed critically; the term "bronchitis" evidently included cases of pneumoconiosis of lungs whose death certificates had to be signed without the advantages of any X-ray or post-mortem examinations, and recent experience suggested that an important number of the deaths returned as bronchitis had been in reality pneumoconiotic. The proportion of these was less easy to estimate since the post-mortem experience by itself would certainly tend to be unduly loaded " with the true pneumoconiotic cases.

The speaker's own experience had been greater amongst anthracite miners, but he had ample evidence of the existence of serious and fatal pneumoconiosis amongst the non-anthracite workers; in all, whether anthracite or non-anthracite, silica in high degrees was the outstanding feature in chemical analyses of the lungs. The age at death averaged 54 in the anthracite workers and 53 in the non-anthracite.

Deaths definitely attributable to pneumoconiosis numbered 30 in all, out of 83 bodies examined. Four others, over 40 years, died of tuberculosis associated with excess of silica in the lungs, and another nine cases died with pueumonia, also associated with an unusual amount of silica in the lungs.

The necessity for devising means to prevent inhalation of siliceous dust by coal miners appeared to be very definite and urgent.

Dr. H. A. SCHOLBERG (Cardiff) said he subscribed without reservation to the statement made by Prof. Cummins that mechanical factors were to be accepted as the initial and obvious cause of the lung changes which led to the physical failure and invalidity that eventually overtook the collier. He would emphasise the fact that during active, strenuous work, respiration was quicker and deeper, and the lungs were over-distended with air and engorged with blood. Dust, which in the resting condition would not reach the deeper parts of the lungs, was in a dust-laden atmosphere under working conditions distributed to lung areas which were not always distended. When work ceased, such areas collapsed and the dust particles were incarcerated and became absorbed. The process of absorption led to destruction of the air-spaces of the lung, and a diminution of the lung available for respiration during active work. This was an important cause of inefficiency in output of work, the measure of this being taken as extending over the years when deterioration sets in up to the time of total physical failure. This must represent a loss of working hours, which was none the less considerable because not recognised. He should like to draw attention to the fact that silicon in its compounds could he an integral and essential constituent of animal and vegetable life. Silicon compounds clearly had chemical characters which made it possible for them to enter into the metabolic processes of organic life. On biological grounds, it was reasonable to contend that a portion of the silica, and the silicates inhaled during active work, could gain entrance to cells and be present there in the colloidal form, and in assuming the gel form could give rise to nodules of stony hardness, as was shown by T. Graham many years ago, when he demonstrated that silica gels lose water as they age, even though they are kept under water. These general considerations, drawn from the biological and chemical side, helped to justify the thesis that dusts which can enter living tissues and destroy its normal functions, however slowly, should be eliminated as far as possible.

A Case for the Engineer.

Dr. P. E. WILLIAMS (Blackwood, Mon.) said he was very glad that Prof. Cummins pointed out that the doctors must hand over the prevention of silicosis to the engineers. In his opinion the prevention of most industrial diseases was ultimately a problem for the engineer. However, if they were to expect results they must not set the engineering profession too great a problem. To ask the mining engineer to prevent all forms of dust was to ask too much; they should tell him which were the most fatal and needed urgent attention. As Dr. Cummins pointed out, coal dust alone was easily got rid of from the lung, and obviously it could not give rise to silicosis. He thought, however, if a lung was already damaged by silica dust, though not so advanced as to be labelled a case of silicosis, then shale and coal dust would add to the damage and overload the lungs and destroy its functioning power.

Referring to men described as coal miners who are proved by X-ray and analysis of lungs to be cases of silicosis, he felt convinced, if their industrial history could be probed sufficiently, it would be found that they had done periods of boring or such work had been going on near their working places. He believed also that in many cases the N-rays showing shadows suggesting silicosis were due to ordinary stone and coal dust invading the lung already if their industrial history could he probed sufficiently. He would like to add his thanks to Dr. Cummins and Dr. Weatheral for finding the scientific explanation to the very common belief that coal dust prevented pulmonary tuberculosis. It was cases such as he had referred to which he thought would benefit most from a suitable respirator.

The dust arising from a rock containing a high percentage of free silica was universally recognised as dangerous, and in his experience, gained chiefly in the Western Monmouthshire valleys, the dangerous dust and the dust for which there was the most urgent need of careful trapping, was that which arose out of boring or blasting the "grits" or "sandstones," such as the Pennant grit. In the post-mortems he had attended, he had not come across one which showed macroscopic evidence of silicosis or fibrosis with loss of breathing power, whose industrial history also did not show that he had worked for periods of many months or years in the local grits and sandstones.

Considered from the point of view of the coal field community, it was very desirable and lie thought it would certainly prove of financial benefit to the companies to keep silica dust under control, not only in order to keep down the number of those who might become certifiable as suffering from and disabled by silicosis, but it would prolong the age limit of the full-working capacity of time miners. Whilst some companies took precautions to prevent excess of dust, others did not. If this state of affairs was allowed to continue, in the course of time the more progressive companies would be called upon to pay for the dust made by the other companies in compensating men who would inevitably drift into their employ from less hygienic conditions.

Dr. Cummins also had hinted at a very important aspect of dust prevention when he stated that he had heard that the miner "will not wear a respirator of any sort." This was partly true. He had even known of cases where the expensive dust receivers had been mishandled and spoiled, and more frequently cases where men found it too much trouble to use them. If they acquiesced and allowed this attitude to become a common one the whole campaign against dust would be futile. He would go so far as to say that a second or third offence of this kind should entail dismissal and forfeiture of right to compensation. At the present time, especially, the colliery companies should not be asked to spend more unless every effort were made to ensure a full return for their expenditure.

Tuberculosis Amongst Coal Miners.

Dr. R. MELVILLE HILEY (Tuberculosis Institute, Pontypridd) said as a result of a not inconsiderable experience as a clinician and radiologist he was definitely of opinion that cases of silicosis did occur, and by no means infrequently, in the steam coal areas of South Wales. Contrary to generally accepted opinion, be stated that lie had met cases of silicosis who had never worked in hard ground or used a blast drill. This raised the important question as to whether the combined silicates were the harmless and innocuous substances they were supposed to be. He felt justified in making a definite diagnosis of silicosis in these cases in view of the fact that they presented (1) the symptoms of silicosis; (2) also had X-ray films which were identical with one or other of the recognised types of silicosis; and (3) all other causes which would be likely to be associated with such fibrosis had been carefully excluded. Further, these X-ray appearances were not seen in the vast majority of old coal miners. He was not worried by the nomenclature. Whether they were called cases of silicosis, silicatosis or silico-anthracosis, was immaterial from the point of view of diagnosis — as to the clinician, they were the same thing. The workers were definitely of opinion that the dusting of the roadways was responsible for their trouble. He knew of one instance where a roadway had actually been dusted before a sample was submitted for examination. When this examination was carried out by a competent authority the "dust" turned out to be almost pure SiO2. It should not be overlooked that cases of rapidly advancing progressive pulmonary tuberculosis were associated with silicosis in colliers. He thought that a good many of the bronchitis cases had a silicous basis. He wondered whether there was such a thing as "tolerance" in dust. He had met cases who had worked for 20 years in hard headings in whom there was not the slightest suggestion of silicosis, whereas other workers who had only worked in hard ground for short periods had definite evidence of silicosis.

No Satisfactory Mask.

Dr. SYDNEY W. FISHER (H.M. medical inspector of mines), in a written communication, said Prof. Lyle Cummins' observations on the development of pulmonary fibrosis in certain workers in coal mines were in agreement with those of most other observers. He bad not had brought to his notice a single case of disabling or fatal pneumoconiosis in a coal miner who had not drilled in rock for a certain period in his working history. The term "silico-anthracosis" was certainly apt. If, in future, it was proved that a coal miner might be disabled by or die from the effects of the inhalation of coal dust alone, legislation would require a new term for a distinct disease. The need for dust-prevention was fully recognised experiments with various dust-collecting devices were constantly being carried out and receive the undivided attention of an inspector of mines. Respirators of various types had been given trials, but a completely successful mask had not yet been designed. The main difficulty was to produce one which would prevent the inhalation of dust and yet not throw too great a strain on breathing, or restrict the freedom of movement of the individual wearing it.

Dr. OWEN L. RHYS (Cardiff) wrote that during the last two years he had made an X-ray examination of 102 cases of silicosis from the South Wales coal field and, in addition to these, he frequently came across cases in the X-ray department of the Royal Infirmary at Cardiff. Two points had specially struck him, namely (1) Many of the bad cases had been working regularly until shortly before he saw them, had failed suddenly, and in a few months were dead; (2) the most severe cases were in men working in one of three or four pits; in one series several men from one district developing the disease very badly, and all failing almost together.

Toxic Properties of Coal Dust.

Prof. GEORGE KNOX (Past-President) said that the diminishing relative liability to phthisis among coal miners particularly tended to support the "antiseptic theory" that the inhalation of dust in coal mines tends to prevent phthisis. If, as Prof. Lyle Cummins' experiments had shown, the direct germicidal action of coal dust was practically nil, the suggestion that the power of coal dust to adsorb and render inert the toxic principle of tuberculin, thus acting as a limiting factor in the spread of phthisis, did provide a clue to the relative difference between the types of cases met with in coal and metalliferous mines respectively If coal dust adsorbed and rendered inert the toxic principle of tuberculin, what other chemical reactions were likely to be produced? It was well known that highly volatile coal duets (particularly those with a high oxygen content) were liable to spontaneous heating by the adsorption of oxygen, and still more so if moisture in small quantities were present. Was it possible that such oxidation took place in the lungs? It was shown that the mortality rate for bronchitis was much greater in the area where coal dust was least liable to oxidation, and pneumonia highest in the area where coal dust was most liable to oxidation. The increase of these non-tuberculous respiratory diseases between 1881 and 1902, referred to by Tatham, coincided with a period of great improvement in mine ventilation, and increased supply of oxygen to the dust in the lungs of miners. If distillates were liberated as a result of oxidation of coal dust in the lungs, this might account for various other inexplicable miners' diseases, such as nystagmus, which it was rumoured had now been traced by German investigators to toxic effects.

Another important point emphasised in the paper was the influence of stone dust in retaining inhaled coal dust in the lungs, thus producing silico-anthracosis. Did the presence of any kind of stone dust in the lungs prevent the transportation of the coal dust (in the interior of phagocytes) or was this inability confined to dusts of a siliceous nature? The introduction of machinery for the production and transportation of coal dust had increased the amount of dust produced, and the neutralisation of the explosibility of this dust by the addition of stone dust had still further aggravated the dust problem. The use of respirators — particularly in conveyor faces — would certainly lessen the danger, if a convenient form could he devised for work under such cramped conditions. The use of nonsiliceous dusts for stone-dusting would also lessen the liability to the contraction of silico-anthracosis, but if miners could be provided with a suitable respirator to wear when travelling to and from the face and pit bottom, there would be little risk of stone dust inhalation by the coal-getter. In ripping and driving hard headings there were, as the author suggested, efficient dust-prevention apparatus available to ensure that dangerous stone dusts from borings could be eliminated from the mine air and thus reduce the risk from silicosis.

The Effect of Moisture.

Mr. W. FORSTER BROWN (London) said he thought the increase in the mortality from bronchitis since 1881, during a time when the general amenities of coal mining were improving, was due to the increased volume of air at increased velocity carrying coal and stone dust in it. It had, in his view, little to do with the use of rock drills; these were not being largely used in coal mining — certainly not in South Wales, in the eighties of last century. The result referred to by the author appeared to be an example of improvements in one direction, bringing in their train disabilities in another; similarly, it would appear that the compulsory dusting of roadways to guard against explosion might result, unless a dust free from silica in a dangerous form is used, in increasing the liability of the miner to the risk of phthisis. The author did not touch upon the question of the presence of moisture in the air-currents. The most effective method of lessening the coal or stone dust carried in the air-current was by watering. This system was largely employed in the South Wales mines at one time before the stone dusting became compulsory. He would like to ask the author what he considered would he the effect of perhaps a less quantity of coal dust carried into the lungs of the miner by a damp current of air in place of a dry one. Would the mechanical or choking action of the dust on the lungs be greater or less when carried in a damp current as compared with a dry current? And do the statistics indicate any difference in the mortality from phthisis and bronchitis as between mines with a damp as compared with a dry air-current? By damp he would indicate a dry mine artificially watered, in contradistinction to a naturally wet mine.

The PRESIDENT said it seemed obvious that the whole question was wrapped up with the nature of the rocks, so that the geology, petrography, and the chemical analysis of those rocks must be considered before the discussion was closed. In view of some of Dr. Haldane's remarks, something should also be heard from H.M. inspectors of mines; and, finally, the mining engineers would have their opportunity of weighing in with their views.

The discussion was adjourned till the January meeting

* Colliery Guardian, Dec. 18, 1931, p. 2033.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print