Bentley Colliery Explosion.
Official Inquiry.
The inquiry into the Bentley Colliery disaster on November 20, when 45 lives were lost, which is being conducted by Sir Henry Walker, Chief Inspector of Mines, at Doncaster, was continued on January 1. Evidence was mainly concerned with the findings of the deputies in charge of the north-east district, where the explosion occurred.
James Maddox, who was deputy on the morning shift of November 20, said he had been on the north-east district for three years. On his first inspection of the coal face, on November 20, he found no gas. In 140's gate he found 1 per cent, of gas in the outbye, and gave instructions for an alteration of the ventilation cloths with a view to improvement. He re-visited the district and found conditions the same, with an improvement in 140's old gate. Witness said there was no heating at the back of a pack between 144's and 143's. He did not find on the day of the disaster any gas in the wastes. In his examination he did not go beyond the props, but he could reach into the cavity, and found no gas. They were never short of stone dust and it was put down very freely.
Answering Mr. Frowen (Deputies' Association), witness said when he finished work on November 20 there was little gas to report. It was in a small recess in a gate end. He did not think a fall in 148's stall affected a heating between 141's and 142's. Witness's attention was drawn to a crack or lifting in the floor of 143's about a week before the explosion, and to a report made by a workman named Hemstock. Witness agreed that the crack extended about 3 yd., but denied that any gas was being given off while he was there. Hemstock did not report to him that gas was being given off, and that he got a headache.
Answering Mr. W. Stewart (for the colliery company), witness said there were plenty of men for dealing with all the work and for supervising the district. The district was absolutely safe, in his opinion, on November 20, when he left. There was nothing, in his opinion, about 145's gate that could have had anything to do with the explosion. When he had made tests of the face for gas, he had found it one of the cleanest he had ever been on.
William Follows was called following a request made the day before by Sir Henry for the boy who accompanied a rescue worker named Oakland. Follows said he was working on 140's haulage when the explosion occurred. There came a gust of wind, and for some time he could not see, even by his lamp hanging at his waist. It blew him into some tubs. He came across Oakland, and together they did rescue work as described earlier by Oakland. Witness also described another rescue, and was complimented by Sir Henry on his actions.
Edward G. Swift, who worked as a deputy on the same district, said when he left at 4.20 p.m. he saw no sign of heating. There was practically no trace of firedamp. He should put it at 1 per cent. None of the men in the stalls had reported gas during the seven months witness has been in the district. He was not aware that some men in some stalls were not capable of testing for gas. He did not agree with a witness, Moult, when he said three shovelfuls of hot material had been taken from the pit from a previous heating. Witness said there were two pieces about an inch in diameter got out, copper colour. Witness said that His Majesty's inspectors of mines had lived practically at Bentley Colliery, but so far as he was aware there had not been an inspection of the pit by the men's inspectors during the past seven months.
James Hughes, who was the deputy on the district when the explosion occurred, said he had never seen any red material in 140's new cross gate. He had made his first inspection of the district on the day of the disaster 5 min. before the explosion occurred. He was then in 140's junction. Giving a description of what occurred, witness said there was a flash of wind and dust, and he ran to the phone and got through at once to the office. He then went to 148's stall and worked through to the left until they got into 144's and 143's. In 147's appearances suggested the men had been blown into the left end of the bank from the junction of 146's. Props were blown out, and at 145's gate end 10 yd. of timber had been blown away. There was not a stick left standing. No. 144's was not so badly disturbed, and after setting a prop or two they turned that into a dressing station. In 145's the roof from the coal face to the lip edge appeared to be falling, it sagged down about a yard. By the time he got to 143's help had arrived, and he fell back. Some time later, the witness added, he was sent on an errand, and saw the fire in 140's cross gate, looking through a door. Burning wood was dropping down.
Mr. J. Hall (Miners' Federation) asked witness whether, suppose he had been a deputy paid by the State instead of the colliery company, his inspection would have been keener than it was on that particular afternoon. Witness said it would not.
The inquiry was adjourned till the following Wednesday.
On the resumption of the inquiry, on Wednesday, Bernard Frost, overman in charge of the north-east district, said on the afternoon of November 20 he had no flame safety lamp. He was with Deputy Swift, who had a lamp and made an examination. There was no sign of gas or heating. The practice in dealing with heatings was to dig down to the floor, excavate the material from underneath the conny coal to about 2 ft., and fill in with sand and pack with bind. If the heating extended more than 2 ft. under the conny coal they would go after it and take out all the heatings. In this case in 140's cross-gate by 142's gate, all the heated material had been dug out. The heating in 145's had been subdued at the time of the explosion. Replying to further questions, witness said he had known of a fire which broke out in a district now sealed off. He was at home at the time but he understood there was no sign of it in the morning and that in the afternoon there was an active fire. Witness added that there had been no change in the method of treatment of heatings at Bentley Colliery, recently, but for a considerable time the treatment adopted was to dig out everything. The present method had been in existence for 21 years to his knowledge. So far as he knew there was no better method of dealing with heatings.
William White, another overman on the north-east district, said on the Thursday before the disaster the brattice cloth ventilating the left bank at one end in 140's stall was disarranged. Mr. D. McGregor found 1 per cent, of gas in that end. He told the stallmen they would be reported. After the explosion it was impossible for some time to proceed along the return airway towards the face. From 140's old cross-gate he saw smoke and heat in the return way. He always took a flame safety lamp with him into the pit. Witness said steel props had a tendency to increase the fractures in the roof. The practice of dealing with a heating was to go into the ground sufficient to build a sand pack round it. They did not always take out all the heating.
Samuel Temperley, of Arksey, assistant surveyor, described the part he played in the rescue work. When he was with Mr. E. H. Frazer and Major Humphrys (H.M. inspectors of mines) after they had passed 141's gate there was another explosion. Major Humphrys and witness flung themselves on to their faces. Flames came from behind him, apparently from a waste between 140's and 141's. There was just a puff, which soon passed over them. They got up and walked through the fire into 140's cross-gate and into 142's junction. The others had gone back along the coal face. Later, witness added, he accompanied Mr. Frazer to 140's cross-gate, but they could not get in because it was so full of smoke and they could see flames ahead. Witness gave further details of the conditions in the pit and of rescue efforts, and at the conclusion of his evidence Sir Henry said: "You have given us a stoic account of what you did. I have congratulated you before and I do so again publicly."
Mr. Percival L. Collinson, H.M. junior inspector of mines, after giving details of examinations and of his call to the pit on the night of the explosion, described his observations after the first explosion. Witness said he travelled from 148's to 141's. He saw smoke from a fire in 142's right bank and smoke issuing from 142's waste to 140's. He found three bodies, two lying almost head together on the floor. In 142's he found a break in the roof extending to the right-hand pack, but no sign of a fire there. In 141's left bank he saw a burning wooden prop in the gate side pack. Small flames had just come. Witness gave orders for this part of the prop to be got out and he understood the prop was smothered with sand. There was a fire between 141's gate and 142's gate on the left-hand side. It was in the timber at the back of some steel arches. The fire was just going up into the roof. After a rest he accompanied Mr. Herbert Smith and others to the face at 148's. Another explosion occurred about 145's and it was decided to retire. Asked for his theory of the explosion, witness said he thought the explosion travelled from left to right along the face from 140's fast end to 148's. He did not think it extended beyond 149's left bank and suggested it originated in the waste between 141's gate inbye to 140's cross-gate. He put it down to spontaneous combustion. It seemed probable there had been heating from time to time in the waste and he suggested there had been heating in the waste on the left side of 141's gate before the explosion actually occurred. From the evidence of Mr. Temperley something took place in the wastes, and this was the cause of the second explosion. The opening of a door, he thought, brought firedamp from the wastes on to the material that was at ignition point. The opening and shutting of the door would have a sort of bellows effect on the waste on the left side. He ruled out the possibility of an explosion having occurred in 143's, 144's, or 145's gate. The flames as they travelled along would pick up gas from the wastes.
Replying to Mr. Herbert Smith, witness said his experience of Bentley Colliery extended over 2½ years, and in that time he had made 21 inspections. In none of his inspections had he found any heating.
Mr. Smith was asking the witness about variations in evidence when Sir Henry Walker said it was for him to judge as to evidence.
Mr. Smith said he did not intend being pushed about. He was not going to ask the inspector whether he (Mr. Smith) was right or not.
Sir Henry Walker: I am going to tell you.
Mr. Smith: It is interference all the time, trying to curb evidence. It is not for you, my friend, to decide how I shall examine this witness.
Sir Henry Walker: Yes it is. I am empowered to hold this inquiry how I like, and I will hold it as and how I like. I give you a great deal of rope.
Answering Prof. Wheeler (Safety in Mines Research Board), Mr. Collinson said he did not think coal dust played any part in the explosion; he thought it was firedamp from between 140 and 141's. In reply to Mr. Stewart, witness said his theory of the explosion was that between 140 and 141's there had been smouldering spontaneous combustion for possibly two months in the wastes between the cross-gate packs and the face, and that there was an explosive mixture of gas. He agreed that this could be ignited by a defective lamp.
At yesterday's bearing Mr. P. L. Collinson, asked if, in his view, a heating which it was believed had played an important part in the explosion had been in existence from the end of September without giving indication at all, replied in the affirmative. He thought there was not much early increase of temperature, but finally it increased rapidly. There had been instances of heating lying apparently dormant for a year and then coming up again.
Capt. C. B. Platt, superintendent testing officer of the Mines Department Testing Station, gave evidence of testing certain lamps said to have come from the district of the pit after the explosion occurred. One of the electric lamps, he said, might have ignited firedamp under certain conditions. The damage to the lamp referred to was in a stall where a full tub of coal had been blown into a pack and embedded, and a steel prop had been knocked out. So that it would be likely that the damage to the lamp was caused by the explosion rather than it was the cause of the explosion.
A. Clay, a deputy who was brought to the north-east district to assist after the explosion, said he saw smoke in 142's and thought it was coming out of the waste. In 140's cross-gate timber was on fire over the top of steel arches. Witness and others chopped it down and "killed" it with sand taken from sandbags at a door. He thought the timber was fired by the explosion.
Mr. D. Macaskill, who has been superintendent of the Doncaster Rescue Station for 18 years, and who was quickly on the scene, described the scenes during the rescue operations.
Mr. Herbert John Humphrys, Doncaster, senior inspector of mines, said he did not inspect Bentley Colliery for heatings for some time before the explosion. He made one inspection soon after the explosion while assisting the rescue work. His theory was that the explosion originated in 140 or 141's stall, and the most probable cause was a small quantity of gas in the area of 141's gate, 140's cross-gate, and the length of face in between — the same place as Mr. Collinson had suggested. He thought it was propagated by firedamp mixture drawn from successive wastes. He was of the opinion that the flame and gas at the origin of the explosion travelled as far as the gas in the next waste and ignited it, then went on from waste to waste and so on. The effect of the colliery standing would be to form breaks and crush coal, and air would be drawn through the crushed coal. In preventing gobfires they should try to exclude as much air from the goaf as possible, and try to prevent pressure differences. It was the acute pressure itself that was a cause of the trouble, but he was sure that the subject had received adequate consideration at Bentley Colliery. He did not think coal dust played any part in the explosion.
In reply to Mr. Frazer, Mr. Humphrys said the subject of coal in packs should receive very serious consideration, because the coal was subject to disintegration and the packs were subject to air pressure which led to uneven settlement of the roof. He would recommend solid stowing if it were possible to obtain the necessary material, preferably by air pressure. Later, he said he did not think there was enough stuff at Bentley to build packs; there was an alternative of more men being killed by falls.
Mr. J. Hall (Miners' Federation) asked Mr. Humphrys whether he thought that other parts of Bentley Colliery were as susceptible to combustion, and witness replied that there were districts that were more susceptible. He was satisfied with what was done at Bentley in regard to spontaneous combustion.
Mr. Herbert Smith suggested that heatings were not taken seriously enough. Witness said that was not his experience.
In reply to Prof. Wheeler, witness said he did not entirely subscribe to Mr. Collinson's opinion that there was a period of incubation of three months; if conditions were favourable, he thought they could have heating in a good deal less than that.
Mr. E. H. Frazer, Doncaster, H.M. divisional inspector of mines, said the cause of the explosion might be from flame lamp, or by ignition by spontaneous heating in the goaf. Shotfiring was not carried on at Bentley, and no electricity was in use, and he had disregarded the possibility of matches being the cause. There was a possibility some undiscovered heating might have been the cause. Asked if he had any suggestions to make to obviate a repetition, he said he would remove all flame safety lamps from the stalls and only have them in the hands of trained observers. This observation applied to Bentley only. Some men did not test for gas from one year's end to another. As to spontaneous combustion, more might be done in the way of putting sand in gate side packs, and more cross packs across the waste might be made. The distance from the packs at which fires might break out should be ascertained if possible. That might be 30 yd., and if so, he suggested that cross packs should not exceed that distance apart, so that the weight might be sealed always within the distance in which fire might break out. The non-recovery of the flame lamps prevented the possibility of investigation from that point of view. It was conceivable a door in 140's cross gate was left open and allowed the ventilation to short circuit. Firedamp might have collected and might have made an unattended or defective lamp a source of ignition. An incipient heating might have developed and broken into flame. The most likely place for an undiscovered heating would be the right side of 140's cross gate.
In reply to Mr. Herbert Smith, the witness said he would give a flame safety lamp to every man who was competent and who asked for it, but he would not force one upon them.
Prof. Wheeler suggested it would be better to train every man to use a flame lamp for tests. It was, he said, a counsel of perfection, but that might be the best counsel. Witness agreed.
The inquiry was adjourned.