Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
Items for sale
Items for Sale
e-Books
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

E-Book Prev Page Return to Index Next Page E-Book
/   \

Chapter XXI.

Great Improvement In The Ventilation Of Collieries. — The Steam Jet Tried And Abandoned. — Mechanical Ventilators Come Into Extensive Use.

"There is a spirit of intelligent energy now awakened with reference to this object, from which the best results may hereafter be expected." — Report of the Lords' Committee, 1849.

During the course of the present century the ideas entertained regarding the ventilation of mines have undergone a wonderful revolution, and the extraordinary volumes of air which now sweep through the best-conducted collieries present a striking contrast to the meagre air-currents of the commencement of the century. The life of Mr. Buddle may be regarded as forming the connecting link between the old regime and the new one; the system of compound ventilation, or "splitting the air," introduced by him, was the first step in the direction of improvement, and inaugurated a new era in mine ventilation.

Accustomed, however, as Mr. Buddle was in his youth to the insignificant volumes of air which could alone be introduced into the mines under the system of coursing the air in a single current through the whole length of the workings, and having introduced the new system of ventilation rather with a view to overcoming difficulties connected with the use of the ventilating furnace than with the object of obtaining an increased volume of air, it is perhaps not surprising that he continued throughout most of his life to entertain what to us appear inadequate views on the subject. In 1813, in his communication to Sir Ralph Milbanke, president of the Sunderland Society, he observes that the standard air-current employed in the ventilation of the collieries under his care abounding in inflammable gas moved through an aperture from thirty to forty feet in area, with a velocity of three feet per second, the volume of air being from 5,400 to 7,200 cubic feet per minute. In this standard air-current Mr. Buddle conceived that a maximum of efficiency had been reached, and that in this direction no further improvement could be looked for. Even in 1835 the total volume of air employed to ventilate Wallsend Colliery, with three downcast and two upcast pits, only amounted to 5,000 cubic feet per minute. There is little reason to doubt that inadequate ventilation had much to do with the great loss of life which occurred in the collieries under Mr. Buddle's superintendence. His career was a long and distinguished one, but notwithstanding his great skill and care, and his indefatigable attention to his duties, no fewer than 840 persons are stated to have perished in the pits of which he was viewer.

It was in the newer collieries of the Wear district — where splitting the air was introduced about 1820 — that a commencement was first made to employ volumes of air vastly greater than had been thought of before. This was effected by enlarging the shafts and air-ways, increasing the number of splits and shortening their run, and constructing more capacious (and sometimes several) furnaces. In many cases also great assistance was obtained from the fires of boilers placed underground in connection with steam machinery for hauling the coal, which was coming into common use as a substitute for horses. In 1835, while Mr. Buddle, as we have seen, was ventilating Wallsend Colliery with 5,000 cubic feet of air per minute, at Pensher Colliery (where a special shaft had been sunk for ventilating purposes) the aggregate volume of air sweeping through the mine amounted to 51,900 cubic feet per minute; and at Hetton Colliery at the same time the ventilating current had reached 96,300 cubic feet per minute.

The movement in the direction of better ventilation having once been initiated, the viewers of the period vied with each other in introducing larger and larger volumes of air into the mines, and the above figures were soon left behind. In a statement of the quantities of air circulating through some of the most important collieries in the North of England in 1850, we find Hetton with 190,000 cubic feet, South Hetton and Murton with 132,895 cubic feet, and Wallsend with 121,360 cubic feet per minute.

Within ten or twelve years later the ventilating currents at Hetton Colliery underwent a further enormous augmentation. The ventilating power employed consisted of four furnaces and three boiler fires at Hetton, two furnaces and two boiler fires at Elemore, and one furnace and six boiler fires at Eppleton; and the quantity of air passing through the pits reached the vast total of 450,000 cubic feet per minute.

Among notable instances of furnace ventilation at the present time we have South Hetton and Murton Collieries, with three furnaces and twelve boiler fires, emitting from 380,000 to 440,000 cubic feet; the deep pit at Rosebridge, Wigan, giving, with two furnaces, 235,000 cubic feet; and Wynnstay Colliery, North Wales, with a single furnace, 200,000 cubic feet per minute.

Though furnaces still present the most powerful means of obtaining large volumes of air in the case of deep and dry upcast pits, their use is not free from a number of serious drawbacks. Unless fed with fresh air direct from the downcast pit there is a certain amount of risk of their giving rise to explosion; and if they be not securely isolated from the surrounding strata there is danger of their setting fire to coal seams in their vicinity. Considerable difficulty also exists in executing repairs in the furnace drifts and upcast shafts; while the volumes of smoke poured into the shaft render a furnace upcast a very objectionable passage for the men to traverse in entering or leaving the mine. In addition to this, the operation of relighting the furnace and restoring the ventilation after an accident has occurred is a task of much anxiety and no small danger. These and similar considerations have served as a powerful stimulus to the application of other methods of effecting the ventilation of coal mines.

The experiments made by Mr. Buddle at the commencement of the century were considered to have established the superiority of the furnace over the substitutes which he attempted to employ in lieu of it, but the desirability of excluding fire as much as possible from collieries yielding inflammable gas, continued to lead to various proposals with this object being brought forward from time to time. Mr. Goldsworthy Gurney's scheme for employing jets of high-pressure steam, and Mr. John Martin's proposal to employ a large exhausting fan, both laid before the Select Committee of the House of Commons in 1835, have been already adverted to. These suggestions met with little approval at the time from the mining community, but no long period elapsed before the idea of employing substitutes for the furnace began to be more favourably entertained. The steam jet was strongly recommended by the South Shields Committee in their report published in 1843, and a few years afterwards it came to be actually applied to the ventilation of mines, the first trial of it being made by Mr. T. E. Forster, at Seaton Delaval Colliery, Northumberland, in 1848.

Mr. Forster was led to adopt the steam-jet system of ventilation from having witnessed some experiments at the Polytechnic establishment in London, in June, 1848, with which he was favourably impressed. In November following he applied it in an upcast pit where two boilers already existed having a greater steam-producing capacity than was required for the work they had to perform.

At first the new system promised to be a success, and the favourable accounts of it given by Mr. Forster led to its being adopted at a number of other collieries, viz., Belmont, North Hetton, Usworth, Norwood, &c. But at Seaton Delaval the jet apparatus was applied under peculiar circumstances, there being four downcast pits supplying air to one upcast, and it was not found to give such good results at other places.

The question of the comparative merits of the steam jet and the furnace excited much interest among mining engineers, perhaps more particularly on account of the emphatic approval of the former by the Select Committee of the House of Commons in 1852. The subject was widely discussed and experimented upon, and formed the topic of the first papers read before the North of England Institute in 1852-3. But the numerous elaborate and exhaustive experiments which were made at this time, particularly by Mr. Nicholas Wood, served to establish the undoubted superiority of the furnace both as regards efficiency and economy, and the short-lived popularity of the steam jet speedily came to an end.

 

While steam-jet ventilation was undergoing its trial in the north, a more important innovation on furnace ventilation was being introduced in South Wales. This consisted in the employment of mechanical ventilators driven by steam-engines. These had been in use for a considerable time on the Continent, particularly at the collieries in Belgium, but their regular employment in this country only commenced in 1849, in the early part of which year one of Struve's air-pump machines, and one of Brunton's revolving fans, were erected simultaneously at collieries in Glamorganshire. The former, as first applied at Eaglesbush Colliery, near Neath, consisted of two double-acting airometers, each twelve feet in diameter, and having a stroke of from four to six feet. The latter consisted of a horizontal fan twenty-two feet in diameter, running on a vertical spindle, and placed over the top of the upcast shaft; the first machine being erected at Mr. Powell's Gellygaer Colliery.

During the next few years the use of mechanical ventilators gradually extended. A number of Struve's and Brunton's machines, of various sizes, were built at different collieries in Wales; and in 1852 a form of straight-vaned fan resembling Brunton's, but having the axis horizontal, was introduced by Mr. James Nasmyth; the first being applied at one of Earl Fitzwilliam's collieries, near Rotherham. This fan was only six feet in diameter, but larger sizes were built by Nasmyth shortly afterwards; one being erected at Abercarn, in Glamorganshire, about 1853-4, with a diameter of 13½ feet and a width of 3 feet, followed by a still larger one built for Earl Fitzwilliam. A fan having tangential blades was invented and patented in 1853 by Mr. Biram (viewer to Earl Fitzwilliam), who in the course of the next three or four years applied various fans to ventilate collieries at Elsecar.

The utility of mechanical ventilators was brought before the North of England Institute of Mining Engineers in 1858 by Mr. J. J. Atkinson, Inspector of Mines — a gentleman whose valuable papers contributed from time to time to the Transactions of this Institute served to throw much light on the subject of mine ventilation — in a paper entitled "On the comparative consumption of fuel by ventilating furnaces and ventilating machines, when used to ventilate mines." In this paper Mr. Atkinson adduced statistics exhibiting the superiority of machines in point of economy. As yet no mechanical ventilators had been applied in the Great Northern coal-field, but their introduction took place soon afterwards, an open running fan, similar to those at Elsecar, being erected at Tursdale Colliery, Durham, about 1860.

From this time large numbers of mechanical ventilators of various types came into use. The Guibal fan, with spiral case and flexible shutter (the invention of M. Guibal, of Mons), was patented in 1862, and introduced at Elswick Colliery, near Newcastle-on-Tyne, about 1864, and came so rapidly into favour that within ten or twelve years no fewer than two hundred were at work at collieries in different parts of the kingdom. The Schiele fan, brought forward immediately after the Guibal, and of the same type, has also come into extended use. Waddle fans, open at the periphery and without any exterior casing, have likewise been erected at many collieries. Among other machines of different forms which have been applied to a smaller extent, may be mentioned Lemielle's feathering fan, Nixon's horizontal air-pump piston machine the revolving drum machines of Cooke, and Root's machine resembling in principle the pneumatic wheels of M. Fabry used at collieries on the Continent.

The fear formerly entertained of interruptions to the ventilation being occasioned by mechanical ventilators breaking down, was gradually dispelled as their application was extended, and they were proved by experience to be capable of performing their work with regularity, economy, efficiency, and safety. Of late they have come to be regarded with more and more favour, and are being so largely introduced as almost to promise ultimately to supersede furnaces altogether. The rapidity with which they have recently been adopted is forcibly exhibited by the evidence of some of the witnesses examined by the Royal Commissioners now inquiring into the subject of accidents in mines. Thus Mr. Ralph Moore, inspector of mines for the eastern division of Scotland, stated that the number of fans in use in his district had increased from one in 1873 to upwards of ninety in 1879. Similar testimony in regard to the fan gradually superseding the furnace was afforded by various witnesses, who expressed a remarkable unanimity of opinion in favour of the change.

Of the three forms of fan most commonly used in this country, viz., the Guibal, the Waddle, and the Schiele, the latter is rarely made of a greater diameter than sixteen feet, and is made to revolve with great velocity; while the Waddle and the Guibal are constructed of all sizes up to fifty feet diameter; the latter being frequently from twelve to fifteen feet in breadth, and capable of producing a ventilating current of upwards of 200,000 cubic feet per minute.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page
mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print