Difficulties Experienced In Substituting Coal For Wood And Charcoal In Manufacturing Processes, More Especially In The Smelting Of Iron.
"Alas, what perils do environ
All men that meddle with hot iron!" — Anon.
The same causes which led to the adoption of coal as a substitute for wood in house fires, led in like manner to its gradual adoption for all other purposes of fuel. But in some branches of trade much greater difficulty was experienced in making the change than in others, involving as it did the invention of new arrangements and different processes, or even the removal of the industry altogether to new localities.
Among the manufactures, glass-making was one of the earliest to abandon wood for coal. But little glass was made in England as late as the middle of the reign of Queen Elizabeth, and the little that was made was manufactured in Sussex with wood fuel. A writer of the period (1577) tells us that —
"As for glass-makers they be scant in this land,
Yet one there is as I do understand,
And in Sussex is now his habitation,
At Chiddingsfold he works of his occupation." |
Other glass-houses were established soon after this date, but in all of them wood was the fuel employed.
About the beginning of the seventeenth century, a great impulse was given to English manufacturing industries by the importation of improvements from the Continent, and by the arrival of many foreign adventurers who brought with them a knowledge of numerous appliances which, though long known on the Continent, had not yet been introduced into England. Among these improvements were new forms of furnaces which appear to have been introduced from Germany and Hungary by one Henry Wright about 1610, in which year a patent was granted for employing them to melt bell-metal, &c., with coal instead of wood.
In the following year a patent was solicited for newly-invented furnaces for making glass with coal, a project which occasioned great alarm to Jean Carre, a Frenchman, who had built glass-houses in Sussex and London "at his own great cost," and who entreated the Lord Secretary that the suit might not be granted. The Government, however, was anxious to promote all measures calculated to check the consumption of wood, and Carre's expostulations were of no avail.
The patent for the process of making glass with coal was purchased from the original patentees by Sir Robert Mansell, Vice-Admiral of England, in 1614-15, and immediately afterwards a Royal proclamation was issued prohibiting the manufacture of glass with wood, and also the importation of glass from abroad. King James was himself interested in Mansell's monopoly, having been promised a revenue of £1,000 per annum from it. The King at the same time was amused at his admiral taking to glass-making. He wondered, he said, "that Robin Mansell, being a seaman, whereby he had got much honour, should fall from water to tamper with fire, which are two contrary elements."
On being vested with the glass monopoly, Mansell set gallantly to work to develop the new process ; but the task which he had entered upon proved no light one. He brought over skilled workmen from the Continent to assist him; but for several years all his experiments were abortive. He erected works successively at London, the Isle of Purbeck, Milford Haven, and on the Trent, without accomplishing anything beyond "melting vast sums of money in this glass business." At last, however, his indomitable perseverance was rewarded. About 1619 he tried works near Newcastle-on-Tyne which proved a success, and here the glass trade took root and flourished; the works established by Mansell being carried on uninterruptedly till the middle of the present century. They were long presided over by three families of Huguenot glassmakers, natives of Lorraine, named Henzell, Tytory, and Tyzack, some of whose descendants remain in the district at the present day.
The substitution of coal for wood in the smelting of metalliferous ores, and particularly in the manufacture of iron, was the most important as well as the most difficult industrial problem of the seventeenth century. The idea was not altogether new. As early as 1528 Cardinal Wolsey, then Bishop of Durham, projected a scheme for applying the coal from his mines on the Tyne to smelt the lead from his mines in Weardale, and had a large house and furnace built for the purpose near Gateshead-on-Tyne; but the cardinal's downfall and death occurring soon after, the enterprise was abandoned.
The subject was again mooted in the reign of Queen Elizabeth, and a patent for making iron and steel and melting lead "with earth coal, sea coal, turf, and peat," was granted to Thomas Proctor and William Peterson in 1589. The scheme, however, proved a commercial failure. There is a report relative to the making of two tons of iron by this process, at an iron-work in Yorkshire, from which it appears that the cost of this quantity amounted to two hundred marks (or £66 13s. 4d. per ton), and so, says the reporter, "it is deere iron." And in the hammering of the iron they are stated to have wrought a whole month, night and day, "sondaie and other."
In the above-mentioned patent there is distinct allusion to the subjecting of the fuel to a preparatory process of coking, or cooking — indeed coked peat was the fuel used in the trial referred to — and immediately afterwards we find the treatment of coal in this way made the subject of a separate patent; a licence being granted in 1590 to the Dean of York "to purify pit coal and free it from its offensive smell." But some time elapsed before coked coal came to be applied in the arts.
As the scarcity of wood fuel became more and more felt, the attempts to employ coal in smelting became more frequent, and in the reign of James I we enter upon a regular series of projects for effecting this much desired object. A patent was granted to Robert Chantrell in 1607 "to make and forge iron and steel with stone coal, sea coal, pit coal, and peat coal ;" but no satisfactory results having been achieved, a new patent was granted in 1612 to Simon Sturtevant, a German, whose scheme, as described in his treatise on Metatallica, was of a much more comprehensive character than those which had preceded it. His patent was for a term of thirty one years, and included the making and working of iron, steel, lead, tin, copper, brass, &c., with sea coal, pit coal, earth coal, and brush fuel. The saving expected to be effected by his new processes was set down by Sturtevant at £330,000 per annum. He seems to have been in no hurry to put his projects into execution, in consequence of which, and the fact of his being an outlaw, the patent was cancelled at the end of a year, and a new grant made to John Rovenzon, who had been one of his associates in the enterprise.
But though Rovenzon had secured the patent he appears to have been able to accomplish nothing, and for this reason, after the expiration of some years, another grant was made in 1620 to a company consisting of Sir William St. John, Sir Giles Mompesson, Sir George Ayloffe, knights; Lewis Powell, Walter Vaughan, John Pruthero, and Henry Vaughan, esquires; Henry Stubbs, gentleman, and Hugh Grundy, for "charking" sea coal, pit coal, stone coal, turf, peat, &c., and employing the same for smelting ores and manufacturing metals, and other purposes. The project originated with Grundy, and referred specially to the making of coke by a process invented by him; but notwithstanding the powerful support which he obtained, this enterprise, like the preceding ones, proved a failure, so far as the smelting of minerals was concerned.
One of the chief obstacles to success in the early attempts to smelt with coal, or coke, seems to have been the want of a sufficiently powerful blast. With charcoal fuel a very light blast sufficed. Thus the lead smelters of Derbyshire employed no artificial means to produce a blast, but built their boles, or furnaces, on lofty situations exposed to the west wind, and lighted up their fires when this wind began to blow. Rovenzon (doubtless following Sturtevant's example) employed a wind furnace "to save the charge of bellows." Whether he kept the ore and fuel separate does not appear; by his patent he was at liberty to use furnaces either with or without a division. Grundy and his partners, on the other hand, were restricted to the use of common furnaces in which the fuel and ore were mixed up together; but regarding their experiments, we only know that nothing came out of them.
The first to achieve some measure of success in smelting with coal was Dud Dudley. His efforts were directed exclusively to the manufacture of iron. Dud Dudley was a natural son of Edward, Lord Dudley, of Dudley Castle, Staffordshire. As a boy he took great delight in observing the various processes pursued in the manufacture of iron at his father's ironworks, and thus early acquired some practical acquaintance with the subject. In 1619 Dudley, then twenty years of age, was brought from Baliol College, Oxford, to manage an iron furnace and two forges, belonging to his father, in Pesnet Chase, Worcestershire. When he entered upon the charge of the works charcoal fuel alone was used, but the supply being scanty, and coal abounding in the immediate neighbourhood of the works, notwithstanding his knowledge of the failures which had already attended the attempts of others, he resolved to try for himself whether coal might not be substituted for charcoal.
Having made some alterations in his furnace, Dudley found at his first trial that he could make iron profitably with coal fuel. A second trial was made with the like result; and immediately afterwards he wrote to his father announcing the success of his experiments, and desiring him to obtain a patent for the process. This Lord Dudley forthwith proceeded to do, and a patent, dated 21st February, 1621, "for melting iron ore, making bar iron, &c., with coal, in furnaces, with bellows" was taken out in the name of Lord Dudley himself.
The discovery which Dud Dudley had made, though it has given him an enduring name in the annals of iron smelting, proved disastrous to his personal fortunes and peace of mind. The charcoal ironmasters were bitterly opposed to the new process, and declared the iron manufactured by it to be unfit for use. Even the forces of nature seemed to conspire against him; within a year after the patent was obtained his works were "ruinated" by an extraordinary flood, long afterwards known as "the great May-day flood " — an event which occasioned great joy to the rival ironmasters. Dudley, however, set about repairing his works and recommenced making iron; but so loud were the complaints of its bad quality that he was commanded by King James "with all speed possible, to send all sorts of bar iron up to the Tower of London, fit for making muskets, carbines, and iron for great bolts fit for shipping; which iron, says Dudley, "being so tried by artists and smiths, the ironmasters and ironmongers were all silenced until the 21st of King James" (16 23-4 A.D.). At this time an endeavour was made to get the patent suppressed as a monopoly, but so much importance was attached to the process that it was specially exempted in the general revocation of monopolies which then took place, though the term of the patent was limited to fourteen years. Dudley now went on with his invention cheerfully, but his prosperity was of short duration. For some reason or other his works were taken from him. He does not explain the circumstances, merely intimating that he was ousted of his works and inventions "by the ironmasters and others wrongfully, over long to relate."
Dudley now removed into Staffordshire and started afresh at Himley Furnace, but here he was crippled by the want of a forge, which compelled him to sell his pig-iron to the charcoal ironmasters, who, he tells us, did him much harm by disparaging its quality. This furnace, however, being soon afterwards rented out to charcoal ironmasters, Dudley's operations were again interrupted.
Up till this time the new process had not been much of a success. It had hitherto been carried on in furnaces originally built for smelting with charcoal. Dudley had in consequence been obliged to use very light charges, and had only been able to produce iron at the rate of three tons per week, or about a third of the quantity that could be run in the ordinary way. He now proceeded to erect a new large furnace at Hasco Bridge, Staffordshire, after his own design. This furnace was twenty-seven feet square, and was provided with extra-large bellows. With his improved arrangements he succeeded in making seven tons of iron per week, "the greatest quantity of pit coal iron that ever yet was made in Britain." Near the same place Dudley found the "Staffordshire Thick Coal," and ironstone underneath it, which he proceeded to open out and work. His affairs were now beginning to assume a more prosperous aspect, but his enemies soon found him out. The coal works were no sooner begun than he was forcibly ejected from them, "and the bellows of his new furnace and invention by riotous persons cut in pieces; so that with law-suits and riots being wearied and disabled" he was compelled to desist from his operations, and from this time he becomes lost to sight for a number of years.
In the meantime new schemes for smelting with coal continued to be brought forward. A patent for making iron with coal was granted to William Astell, John Copley, and Francis Croft, in 1627, but they succeeded no better than their predecessors. The matter was next taken up by the learned and ingenious Dr. Jorden, of Bath, who, in 1632, obtained a patent for melting tin, iron, lead, and copper with pit coal, peat, and turf. Dr. Jorden's efforts were specially directed to the smelting of tin with coal, and though he failed to bring his scheme to a successful issue, he remained confident of its ultimate accomplishment.
About this time considerable attention began to be paid to the charring, or coking, of coal, not only in connection with the smelting experiments which were going on, but with a view to its employment for other purposes as well. In 1627 a patent was granted to Sir John Hacket, and one Octavius de Strada (who two years before had been making attempts to smelt with coal in Hainault), for a method of rendering sea coal and pit coal as useful as charcoal, for burning in houses, without offence by the smell or smoke. A. few years afterwards (1633) another patent was granted to a company consisting of Sir Abraham Williams, John Gaspar van Wolfen, Edward Hanchett, Amadis van Wolfen, Walter Williams, Henry Regnolds, John Brown, and Gaspar Frederick van Wolfen, for a new way of "charking" sea coal and other earth coal, and for preparing, dressing, and qualifying them so as to make them fit for the melting and making of iron and other metals, and many other good uses.
During the next three or four years some eight or nine patents were granted for the employment of smokeless preparations of coal; and though the application of coke to the smelting of minerals was not accomplished till long afterwards, it came into use at this time for several other purposes, particularly for making malt. Houghton tells us that up till about 1640 the malt was made with straw fuel in Derbyshire, but that it then came to be made with coke, which occasioned an improvement in the quality of the brewings "and brought about that alteration which all England admired."
A little later an attempt to substitute coke for coal in house fires was made by Sir John Winter. The project is referred to by Evelyn in his diary under date 11th July, 1656, in the following terms
"Came home by Greenwich Ferry, where I saw Sir John Winter's new project of charring sea-coale to burne out the sulphure and render it sweete. He did it by burning the coals in such earthen pots as the glasse-men mealt their mettal, so firing them without consuming them, using a barr of yron in each crucible or pot, which barr has a hook at one end, that so the coales being mealted in a furnace with other crude sea-coals under them, may be drawn out of the pots sticking to the yron, whence they are beaten off in greate halfe-exhausted cinders, which being rekindled make a cleare pleasant chamber fire, deprived of their sulphur and arsenic malignity. What success it may have, time will discover."
Sir John sent some of his "cooked coal," together with a new-fashioned grate, to several great men for a trial, but his project did not succeed.
No sooner had Dr. Jorden failed in his attempts to smelt with coal than the matter was taken up by others. A patent for the purpose was granted, in 1636, to Sir Philibert Yernat, a Dutchman; and another, in 1637, to Vernat and Captain Whitmore. In the following year Dud Dudley again came to the front, and in conjunction with three partners obtained a patent of a more comprehensive character than his previous one, viz., to smelt all kinds of minerals with coal. But he was opposed by Vernat and Whitmore, and before anything had been effected the civil wars came on, and for a period of thirteen years no further trials were made.
In 1651, when the country had become settled again, Dudley made another attempt to set up an ironwork near Bristol. He entered into partnership with Walter Stevens, a linen-draper, and John Ston, a merchant, of Bristol. But after £700 had been expended upon the works, a difference occurred between Dudley and his partners, which involved him in another law-suit, and led to the collapse of the scheme.
In the same year a project to smelt iron with raw coal was set on foot by Captain Jeremy Buck, who obtained at Act of Parliament for the purpose. Cromwell and many of his officers, and many doctors of physic, and merchants, were partners in the enterprise. They appear to have pursued a course similar to Rovenzon, employing wind-furnaces and keeping the ore and fuel separate. Several furnaces were built at great cost in the Forest of Dean. One Edward Dagney, an Italian, and an ingenious glass-maker, of Bristol, made many pots of glass-house clay for them; but they all broke and failed. The partners importuned Dudley to visit their works, and he pronounced it impossible to make iron with coal in pots to profit; but so confident were they of success that they persevered in their own plan and invited Dudley to come back again "to see it effected." The second attempt, however, failed like the first. Afterwards Buck and his partners removed from the Forest of Dean to Bristol, where they erected new works; but here having no better success than before they finally desisted in 1656.
In the following year the matter was taken up by Captain John Copley, who obtained a patent from Cromwell. Copley built a blast-furnace at the coalworks near Bristol, and employed engineers to make his bellows to blow; but after an expenditure of several hundred pounds it was found that the bellows would not work. Dudley (who appears to have resided at Bristol at this time) went to see the works, and told Copley, who was an old acquaintance, that even if his bellows could blow he feared he could not smelt iron with coal. Dudley, moreover, without the help of any engine, made the bellows to be blown "feisibly" by manual labour; but his prophecy appears to have proved correct, as Copley soon abandoned the scheme and removed from the neighbourhood.
Immediately upon the arrival of Charles II in England we find Dudley petitioning to be restored to his estate (which he had forfeited as a royalist), and to his patent for making iron with coal. But he was only one among a crowd of supplicants for Royal favour. He failed to procure a patent; and Colonel Proger, who applied for a patent for the same purpose in the following year, seems to have fared no better.
Notwithstanding the many failures which had attended the attempts to substitute coal for wood in the smelting of minerals up to this time, individuals were not wanting who still continued to hope and expect that this desideratum would eventually be accomplished. "It is to be hoped," wrote Dr. Fuller, in 1662, "that a way may be found out to charke sea coal in such manner as to render it useful for the making of iron. All things are not found out in one age, as reserved for future discovery: and that perchance may be easy for the next, which seems impossible to this generation."
Even as late as 1686 the problem still remained unsolved. Dr. Plot, writing at this time, gives an account of an attempt made in Staffordshire a few years before by Dr. Frederick de Blewstone, a German, to smelt iron with raw coal. He built his furnace at Wednesbury, "so ingeniously contrived (that only the flame of the coal should come to the ore, with several other conveniences) that many were of opinion he would succeed in it. But experience, that great baffler of speculation, showed it would not be; the sulphureous vitriolic steams that issue, from the pyrites which frequently, if not always, accompanies pit coal ascending with the flame and poisoning the ore."
But success was now near at hand. In 1692 a company was incorporated for smelting lead with coal. Leigh tells us in his Natural History of Lancashire that shortly before 1700 iron was being made "by means of cakes of pit coal" (i.e. coke). And at nearly the same time coal was successfully applied to the smelting of both tin and copper. So that as the general introduction of coal for domestic purposes was the distinguishing feature of the coal trade at the close of the sixteenth century, its successful application to the smelting of metalliferous ores may be regarded as marking another epoch in the use of coal at the close of the seventeenth century.