Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
Items for sale
Items for Sale
e-Books
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

E-Book Prev Page Return to Index Next Page E-Book
Explosions in Coal Mines
/   \

Remedial Measures.

That coal dust has some influence in colliery explosions is now generally admitted, and the more the subject has been investigated the more is its importance manifested.

Very few persons are perhaps prepared to go so far as the writers, whose opinion is, that explosions may not only be "intensified" or extended by coal dust, but that they may be entirely supported by it.

Although the correct view is of course an important matter, its bearing on remedial measures is fortunately not so great as might at first sight appear. If the influence of coal dust is admitted to be of so grave a character as to necessitate measures for dealing with the danger, the means employed must be the same, whichever view is held. Until recently no effectual means have been taken. Watering the roadways in dusty pits has been practised for many years, probably as much for convenience and cleanliness as for any other reason; but this watering has been totally inadequate. In all the collieries in which explosions have been described the main haulage roads were said to be watered, but the amount of dry dust on them after the explosions showed that the watering had been of little or no avail. The method usually adopted is to draw water tubs after the engine set, or by horses, the tubs having holes in them for the water to run out on to the road. At best this only wets a part of the floor, and its effect is often not perceptible after a few hours.

If the conclusion as to the origin of the Usworth explosion is correct, it appears that where upper dust exists, the complete absence of bottom dust, owing to permanent dampness of the floor, will not prevent the extension of an explosion by means of coal dust past the wet road.

If the conclusions, as to the origin of the explosions at Seaham, Tudhoe, and Usworth are correct, it appears that the firing of shots on old haulage roads, where there is much dry coal dust, is attended with great danger. It must be remembered that gunpowder is much less frequently used on such roads than in other parts of the pits.

The Trimdon Grange explosion points to the danger of explosions of fire-damp, however small, where they may communicate with and be extended by coal dust.

The West Stanley explosion shows the danger of blasting in dusty workings, where an imperceptible amount of fire-damp may be in the air.

The great loss of life in these disasters largely arose from the highways of the collieries having been traversed by the explosions. These roads were filled with after-damp, and rendered impassable by falls of stone, and the after-damp penetrated the return air ways which were not damaged, so that even, in the numerous eases where the explosions had not injured persons at the working faces, they could not escape. At Seaham Colliery, four workmen, led by an experienced old pitman who had escaped from some other explosions, succeeded in getting out by the return before the after-damp had rendered the air poisonous; and at Trimdon Grange, a few workmen escaped from the Cross-but way, having only to travel a short distance of road, over which the explosion had extended, before reaching the downcast shaft.

In passing from one district to another the explosions always traversed the main intake air ways, and passed to the downcast shafts by these roads, cutting off all communication. No system of dividing the mines into separate districts averted the effects of the explosions, which passed from one district to another by the roads considered least likely.

If the haulage roads could be kept free from coal dust an explosion could not be originated on them, and they would not convey an explosion from one district to another, but might be expected to be as inert, in this respect, as the return air roads were observed to be. The great velocity of the currents of air now common in dusty pits, and necessary for the ventilation of the mines, has a direct tendency to increase the quantity of dust deposited on the roads over which coals are led.

The quantity of dust collecting on haulage roads might be reduced — (1) by reducing the velocity of the air, which may be attained by enlarging or doubling the roads; (2) by reducing the speed at which the tubs travel. The endless rope or chain system of haulage would effect this, the speed of the tubs would not then exceed 3 or 4 miles an hour, as compared with 10 to 15 miles by main-and-tail ropes. In order to prevent dust flying off the tops of the tubs, at one colliery in Durham, a spray of water is made to play upon them as they pass under it. This is said to have considerable effect. The tops of the tubs on engine planes might be protected by tarpaulin covers, one cover being made to pass over a certain number of tubs. The above measures are, however, only palliative.

The removal or efficient damping of dust on the haulage roads is not unattended with difficulty. The dust is constantly accumulating on them, and upper dust is almost peculiar to them. The sides and roof are often very irregular in contour, and much water sometimes causes the strata to disintegrate.

Dust on the bottom may be collected and sent out of the pit, and the floor kept damp by watering. In some cases where the application of water has been difficult or harmful the use of coarse salt has been found beneficial. Its hygroscopic action comes into play and causes the dust to adhere and solidify. When used in conjunction with water the effect is more lasting than when water alone is used.

Water conveyed in ordinary water tubs cannot be applied effectually, as it only wets the bottom, and, generally, only part of that. A much better method is to convey small water pipes, with cocks at frequent intervals, along the roads which require watering; with the aid of a hose a man can then thoroughly water all parts of the road.

In cases where there are special difficulties in the way of effectually removing or watering the dust on haulage roads, the mine might be divided into sections by cutting off the supply of dust at particular places. This could be done by arching a length of road, and keeping it scrupulously free from dust. The top and sides might be whitewashed occasionally, and the bottom dust removed by sweeping or otherwise. What the length of these cleansed places should be would require careful consideration — perhaps 100 yards would suffice. Bottom dust might be rendered uninflammable by an adulterant, such as sand.

The dust in the working places is almost entirely bottom dust, and although it may be quite capable of causing the extension of an explosion over a district, would be unable of itself to extend it to other distant parts of the mine; so that if the haulage roads were kept so free from dust as to be unable to conduct an explosion, each district might be considered separately with regard to dust, something in the same way as they are now considered with regard to fire-damp.

Special precautions are necessary with regard to blasting. Shots should not be fired where there is much dust of any kind, in places where there may also be a small proportion of fire-damp in the air, because even non-combustible dust has the property of causing the ignition of otherwise non-inflammable mixtures of fire-damp and air, when the proportion of fire-damp is so small as to be difficult to detect by the flame of the lamp. This action of non-combustible dust was discovered by Sir F. Abel when experimenting with dust from the South way in No. 3 Pit at Seaham Colliery, where, as has been stated, the dust was largely mixed with stone dust, and over which the explosion did not extend. If dust of any sort is present where there may possibly be a small proportion of firedamp in the air, the vicinity in which the shot has to be fired should be specially watered. The use of dry dust for tamping should be prohibited.

The writers believe that the chief danger of shot firing in coal mines is due to coal dust. The greatest precautions have long been taken in regard to fire-damp where shot firing is concerned, and if equal precautions were taken with regard to coal dust, it is probable that the danger arising from the use of explosives would be so reduced as to allow of greater freedom in their use than would otherwise be possible. In mines free from dust, the existing restrictions as to the use of explosives might be considerably relaxed.

A more drastic remedy may be suggested. From what has been said before, it appears that the dryness of collieries depends on two causes — (1) the temperature of the mine being higher than the temperature of the air entering the mine; (2) the large volumes of air constantly circulating. Thus, a large volume of air entering the mine at 40 degs., and raised in its course to 70 degs., exercises an enormous drying power. If the air entering the mine was artificially raised to the temperature of the mine, and saturated with moisture, it could exercise no drying power, and the natural moisture of the mine would then come into play, and dry pits might become damp pits.

The objections to this proposal may be stated thus :— The expense of raising the temperature of the air, and saturating it; if the heating were effected as the air descended the downcast shaft it would oppose the ventilating power; the moist air would have a bad effect on the roof stone; moist air at a high temperature is not so agreeable to workmen as dry air at the same temperature; in the case of dip workings, (as at Usworth, where the face lay 160 yards below the shaft bottom, and the temperature of the rock at the face would be 8 degs. higher than the temperature of the rock at the shaft), air heated to the temperature of the rock at the shaft, and saturated, would rise in temperature as it proceeded in-bye and became dry.

The advantages might be, if the mine really became damp :— Large explosions, such as the five Durham explosions, would not be possible; the expense connected with the removal of dust might be avoided; shot firing might be practised with reference to the danger arising from gas only.

The operations necessary on the occurrence of serious colliery accidents are of such a difficult nature, and the investigation of explosions involves so many obscure questions, that it appears desirable to have special means for these purposes; as well for endeavouring to rescue survivors as for making the observations necessary to discover the causes of the accidents. At present everything has to be arranged and organised on the spur of the moment, under circumstances of great confusion. Few attempts are made to take intelligent and methodical observations until the opportunities for doing so are lost. All endeavours are naturally, primarily, bent on the rescue of survivors and the recovery of the bodies of the victims.

Explosions or serious accidents are not so common as to render it necessary that each colliery should be provided with all the appliances likely to be of service. For the same reason, the number of persons with much practical experience concerning them is limited.

A central institution might be formed in each large mining district, where all the necessary appliances and instruments might be kept, and a corps of experts, and volunteers from the collieries, trained in their use. A controlling staff of mining engineers and scientific men might be enrolled, who would make the arrangements necessary for the efficient service of the institution, and for the observation and recording of such facts as would appear likely to throw light on the causes of the accidents. They would hold themselves in readiness to proceed at once to the scene of an accident, and by means of relays secure the intelligent observation of everything likely to elucidate their cause, as well as endeavour to rescue survivors, and secure the safety of explorers. Rules might be drawn up for the guidance of persons assisting at or investigating different classes of accidents. Members of the institution might be delegated to attend accidents in other districts for the purpose of obtaining practical information and rendering assistance.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print