Brief Observations, &c. &c.
A PAMPHLET having been put forth, bearing the title of a "Voice from the Coal Mines,"
and professing to be a faithful detail of the numerous grievances of the Colliers on the Tyne
and Wear, the following summary remarks are meant to place a few of the stipulations contained
in the Pitmen's Bond, which are deemed so grievous, in a more correct point of view: but with
no unfriendly feeling towards the colliers; who, from having in late years, during the ferment
of public opinion, and the more recent mischievous combinations amongst the workmen in the
manufacturing districts, conducted themselves so peaceably and creditably, it is the more to
be lamented that they should have permitted the "Voice" to issue under their
sanction ; as, from its exaggerated and inflammatory statements, it is only calculated
to irritate the coal-owners, whom it somewhat insidiously endeavours to conciliate, at
the expence of the agents, placed in more immediate contact with the workmen.
The "Voice" details, under 12 divisions, and numerous sub-divisions, a variety
of complaints, which may be presumed as meant to apply to that number of collieries ;
but as these are not specified, it is quite impossible to discuss the divisions individually ; which, however, is the less material, they being merely repetitions, and revolve themselves
into the following heads :-
"THE COAL MEASURE."
The peck is stated to contain 18 instead of 16 quarts : now it is well known that pecks
and quarts are not the proper mode of estimating this measure, the datum for which is
the standard chaldron, stated in all coal contracts and leases to contain 24 bolls of
36 gallons each ; and as 8 pecks are a coal boll, the peck must consequently thus
contain 18 quarts. Upon this principle, it is perfectly well known to all conversant
in the trade, that the coal measure tub has always been regulated, and stamped, by
the proper authorities in Newcastle. The hewing price per score for this measure,
must of course depend on the particular circumstances of each colliery, and the
settling this amount properly constitutes the principal subject for treaty between
master and man at each yearly colliery binding.
"LAID OUT AND SET OUT CORVES"
Previous to the collieries being wrought on the separation system, corves needed
only to be laid out for stones ; but now that large coals are in such request, in
both the London and coast markets, a great advance in the hewing price (about 2-5ths)
is given for obtaining this description of coal, and, owing to the anxiety of the
agents to send their respective coals to market in the best possible state, forfeits
have arisen to prevent an admixture of small. The amount of these fines is generally
from 6d. to 1s. per corf; and while it is in candour admitted, that 6d. and 1s.
forfeits seem excessive, it may be doubted whether it would not be quite as well
for the coal-owner's interest, if they were reduced, even only to the forfeiture
of the corf, as it is a well-known fact that the poor abused "keekers"
are, in their indulgence to the men, in the habit of allowing many corves to pass,
which in strictness ought to be condemned — only "laying out"
the shamefully foul, and small corves. As to the ludicrous proposition of each
hewer running from the board face to pick the stones out of his own corf, which
are not seen until turned over into the waggon or heap, the men themselves would
laugh at the idea, if seriously proposed to them — the coals being frequently
shipped ere the hewer comes to hank, If, however, the integrity of the owner's
"keeker" is so doubted, perhaps the masters might be induced to allow
the pitmen the privilege of appointing and paying a "keeker" of their
own, and the two inspectors might, by given rules, decide the matter, and the
like in respect to
"SET OUT,"
Regarding which it is quite impossible the masters can ever consent that the
forfeit shall only extend to the quantity actually found deficient, as every
corf might thus have to be measured, which, besides the expence and loss of
time, would seriously injure the coal.
The fine for heating the boys can only be objected to by some ill-natured fellow
having no children of his own. Ask the mothers whether they would wish this to
be rescinded ?
The fine of 2s. 6d. for not working, is seldom exacted, except from the decidedly
idle and disorderly, — and if a man wish for a day to himself, on proper
occasions, on application to the office for this purpose, he is not refused. But
how does this correspond with the more substantial complaint of a dearth of work
during three fourths of the year, and which has this season been certainly more
than usually the case, owing to the general deficiency of vend ? The masters
might, indeed, have permitted the coals to be wrought, but for what purpose,
except encumbering the surface of the country ? Besides, it is well known that
the coals deteriorate so much by exposure to the weather as to become nearly
unsaleable.
That the coal-trade is so irregular, is to be regretted but the masters have
unluckily no control over the seasons, and cannot compel their customers to
store their cellars at the convenience of the coal-owners, who suffer quite
as much from the fluctuation in the demand as the hewers. Indeed, to the
latter, in an enlarged view, its being disadvantageous may be questioned ;
for, as a general principle, it will be admitted, that wherever work is
inconstant, wages are higher. To men with families this is perhaps less
applicable.
To sum up the subject of the fines, it may be with confidence stated, that
the average deductions of the leading collieries will not amount to 2s. per
man per fortnight, or 52 shillings per annum, even including in this sum the
stoppages for house-rent and firing, which two latter only, if provided by
the pitmen themselves, would cost them considerably more than the whole
amount above stated ; and yet this system is described as being more
tyrannical than afforded by the annals of "Tunis or Algiers !"
The complaints of imperfect ventilation can scarcely in any instance be correct.
Generally it must be allowed, that in no part of the kingdom is the system
so well understood, or such pains taken, and expence incurred, in effectually
airing the mines.
It was intended to remark upon a few more of what, it is now hoped, may not
improperly be termed misstatements of the "Voice ;" but the fear
of being too diffuse induces the writer to conclude with a few general observations.
The motive of the "Voice," in its distorted statements, is evidently
to induce a belief that the prices for pit-work are insufficient for the labour,
and inadequate to the maintenance of the workmen and their families. Now to
shew the fallacy of this, it may be sufficient to refer to the 6th Rule of
their own Union, which prohibits any member thereof earning more than 4s. 6d.
per day, coupled with the fact, that this said sum can be earned in the
leading collieries by 6 hours actual labour! And yet, though they can and
have frequently made 7s. or 8s. per day by stopping in the pit 10 or 12 hours,
(and men unshackled by the Union are now actually making this sum,) the Union
Men refuse to earn more than 4s. 6d. per day, though ever so essential to
their master's interest; which certainly seems the more unaccountable and
unfeeling to their own families, described as being in "rags,"
"poverty," and "starvation." And on the subject of
earnings, it may be further affirmed, that industrious hewers have, upon
an average of the last 10 years, received from their masters not less than
£50 a year each, clear of all deductions whatever ; and that many
families, who have young men and boys, have been in the receipt of two
hundred, and even two hundred and fifty pounds per annum. Compare these
earnings with those of the robust agriculturist, or sedentary weaver,
and enquire of the hewer whether he will change "Kavels?"
It would, perhaps, have been more becoming and consistent with the spirit of
christianity, so irreverently assumed by the "Voice," if the pitmen,
instead of treating their masters in such disrespectful terms, by attributing
to them "Tyrannical, fraudulent, inhuman, and unjust conduct," had
allowed themselves a few moments of sober reflection, for the purpose of
taking a retrospective view of their situation for the last 30 years, and
comparing the past with the present, in which case it would be a libel upon
their character, as men and Englishmen, not to believe that gratitude and
respect would have been the prominent feelings of their breasts, instead of
the opprobrious epithets which they have been seduced to bestow upon their
masters.
The "Voice," though affecting to joke about the coal mines being
more properly denominated gold ones, does not appear, however, to entertain
any very exalted idea of the profits arising from their produce; and it is
to be regretted, that this should be the only point where the Coal-owners
and the "Voice" can at all approximate, — the fact being,
that the large property embarked by the coal-owners, yields, perhaps, taken
as a whole, the least return of any business in the kingdom employing a
similar amount of capital, though coal-mining is confessedly the most
precarious of speculations.
The writer, in conclusion, requests to offer what is really meant as a
friendly admonition to the pitmen generally, to pause before they attempt
an open rupture with their employers, who, it may be relied upon, are at
least wise and courageous enough not to be intimidated or controlled by
any Union or combination amongst their workmen, or suffer any single colliery
to be injured by the strike of the Union Men employed thereon ; and should
a general strike take place, whatever temporary difficulty might be felt
by the coal-owners here, inconvenience by the consumers in the Metropolis,
or embarrassment by the stagnation of trade in the Counties of Northumberland
and Durham, it does not require the gift of prophecy to foresee that the
consequences must prove most distressing and disastrous to the misled
colliers and their families.
Quayside, Newcastle, November 22, 1825.